AfterWorld Survival Forum
Discussions => Gameplay Discussions => Topic started by: Event "Janе" Horizon on July 10, 2014, 07:19:27 am
-
Player will no doubt correct me if I am wrong (I have been doing different type of skilling than FPS over the last 2 years) ..
The rate of SAU gained against a creature is currently an indication of whether you are skilling against the right creature for your skill level (or not).
A low SAU rate while using a item that has 100% SAU & 100% Skill gain rate indicates that you are using the wrong creature.
Note: this is different to the SAU gain rate of the item - that value is item vs player. This query is player & item vs creature.
The same applies to Avoidance - expect this is purely skills vs creature.
Will we be getting another type of indicator that helps us know when we are on the wrong creature (e.g. the creatures name has different colors)?
Or will this concept disappear with the new version, making all creatures equal for skilling?
-
Player will no doubt correct me if I am wrong (I have been doing different type of skilling than FPS over the last 2 years) ..
The rate of SAU gained against a creature is currently an indication of whether you are skilling against the right creature for your skill level (or not).
A low SAU rate while using a item that has 100% SAU & 100% Skill gain rate indicates that you are using the wrong creature.
Note: this is different to the SAU gain rate of the item - that value is item vs player. This query is player & item vs creature.
The same applies to Avoidance - expect this is purely skills vs creature.
Will we be getting another type of indicator that helps us know when we are on the wrong creature (e.g. the creatures name has different colors)?
Or will this concept disappear with the new version, making all creatures equal for skilling?
Good point. Either the system will change or we need a new indicator.
Hope the dev team has thought about it already, but doesn't hurt to remind them about this.
-
Just to clarify, it doesn't matter what mob you're shooting with a rifle, the SAU gained on average is completely dependent on the SGR of the rifle itself. Whether you're shooting slugroaches or tallofooters you'll still get the same SAU on average for the same number of successful shots. You get no SAU at all still from missed shots.
But your question is definitely still value with respect to avoidance skills. The only way to know if your avoidance skills are getting their maximum benefit is by the amount of SAU gained when a given mob hits you. If we won't be gaining anything but skill points after SAU is removed (assuming P Notes will not be gained in this way) it'll take a lot more effort to figure out which mobs to use for the best skill gains.
-
Am I correct in saying that as Avoidance skills rise, not only does the average damage done by a mob fall, but it also hits less often? So that would reduce the rate of skill gain twice over. And does a skill line always represent the same skill increment? Or does one simply have to check how much skill has been gained after an hour say? Not easy.
But now that skills cannot be traded, I suggest the playing style of just skilling Avoidances will be much reduced. On the one hand there is no point doing it to sell them, and on the other hand players who want to progress will not have time as they will no longer be able to buy Weapon skills and will have to spend that time actually killing mobs. So the right choice of mob becomes less which one gives most Avoidance, but which can be killed with the correct level of weapon without being killed oneself.
I should say again here that in my opinion removing skill trading is a grave error, and will make the game unplayable. I see how much time it is taking me to move up around only level 8, and I think very few people will want to invest more time, especially as they will know they cannot sell their skills when they decide to leave.
-
Am I correct in saying that as Avoidance skills rise, not only does the average damage done by a mob fall, but it also hits less often? ...
Creatures always hit 22 times and always do some damage.
Unless you mean Avoidance Strike Through, this seems to be determined by other skill levels.
...I see how much time it is taking me to move up around only level 8...
That is one of those things that I cannot understand ... why the AWA mobs and levels are not present in AWS - level 10 was in reach of players with a reasonable effort in AWA. We'll need to see if DL are really only interested in a FPS type game; or they want to enable other professions.
-
That is one of those things that I cannot understand ... why the AWA mobs and levels are not present in AWS -
yes this loss has been something we have dealt with and expect to be a bug in the system
-
Just put a gain rate at mobs like the current info at items.
-
That is one of those things that I cannot understand ... why the AWA mobs and levels are not present in AWS -
yes this loss has been something we have dealt with and expect to be a bug in the system
Yep, there's a big difference in the variety of mobs between AWA and AWS, which is a result of AWS's mob system not getting as much polished work as AWA's. The devs have mentioned a bunch of new mobs coming in the future though so this will hopefully be fixed with the mob loot balancing update.
Just put a gain rate at mobs like the current info at items.
This may well be something the devs are planning to do. In AWA when you clicked the Info button for a mob it would tell you whether it was tamable or not, which depended on a number of factors, including your taming and training skill levels. It's not a big stretch to think that they'll be implementing a full information window for individual mobs like we have for individual items.
-
Hello everyone. Sorry it took so long to reply, a lot of things are going on.
Weapons will have a new stat, maybe 'Learning effectiveness', maybe something similar. Mobs will have similar stats when you examine them. Those stats will show you how good you can skill on them: good, bad, awful or optimal. We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
-
Thing is its not that hard to stand with a mob and take hits and see if your getting the avoids it should be giving regularly... if it seems a bit slow the avoids gain then stay with the same mob but move up a maturity and see if they are coming faster ...
if you run out of the maturitys and the highest of that mob isn't giving fast enough avoids gains then move to another mob that does the same avoids you want and repeat ... it isn't rocket science,its not that hard at all ... gl
-
OK - let's put it another way.
The majority of the new players will not understand how to measure their avoidance gain against creatures to the extent that they will be able to know when they are skilling against the wrong creature (keeping your eye on the system messages and counting the number of skill point gain messages that appear over several minutes is not an obvious way to measure things - especially as there will be several messages between each skill point message).
This would lead to slow skill level gain and ultimately an impression that the feature is nerfed.
Which then leads to negative reviews.
-
Weapons will have a new stat, maybe 'Learning effectiveness', maybe something similar. Mobs will have similar stats when you examine them. Those stats will show you how good you can skill on them: good, bad, awful or optimal. We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
Super, thanx!
-
Hello everyone. Sorry it took so long to reply, a lot of things are going on.
Weapons will have a new stat, maybe 'Learning effectiveness', maybe something similar. Mobs will have similar stats when you examine them. Those stats will show you how good you can skill on them: good, bad, awful or optimal. We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
Thanks Anti.
Look forward to seeing how these work.
-
Surely Learning Effectiveness on a weapon is the current Skill Gain %.
If not, I am confused, and I expect others are too.
Or is it proposed to replace the exact % with a fuzzy statistic which can have only 4 values?
-
We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
I sugest the 4 or 5 statistics can be easly read be changind mobs HP bar color or name color, or adding a number or something that can be easly be read if is a good target or bad to increase skill(or to weak or hard for us to kill).
I say it because is a pain have to target the mob and press at bar to show the stats and check if is good or not for us.
Hope you understand my english sorry for that.
-
Mobs will have similar stats when you examine them. Those stats will show you how good you can skill on them: good, bad, awful or optimal. We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
let's make a zoo on the other side of the fence to examine them, and kids, players, granny, noobs, dale, popps, should be able to visit the zoo and check there the stats, this could be like was in the old QA, when alarm warned us Fifth jumped the fence and killed someone.
jog on .........jk, ofc
cheers 8)
-
We don't want to show exact numbers or % to make it slightly more realistic (really, you don't know things like that in real life).
I sugest the 4 or 5 statistics can be easly read be changind mobs HP bar color or name color, or adding a number or something that can be easly be read if is a good target or bad to increase skill(or to weak or hard for us to kill).
I say it because is a pain have to target the mob and press at bar to show the stats and check if is good or not for us.
Hope you understand my english sorry for that.
That is a good point.
I am not sure if the game engine has this feature, but maybe some sort of hover mouse --> tool tip with mob details?
-
" noobs, dale, popps"
I think I have been called a noob. since noobs and popps are....
-
Thing is its not that hard to stand with a mob and take hits and see if your getting the avoids it should be giving regularly... if it seems a bit slow the avoids gain then stay with the same mob but move up a maturity and see if they are coming faster ...
if you run out of the maturitys and the highest of that mob isn't giving fast enough avoids gains then move to another mob that does the same avoids you want and repeat ... it isn't rocket science,its not that hard at all ... gl
I agree with Cuey, it's most definitely not rocket science.
How easy does the game need to be made, I am pretty surprised that people feel the need to have written information in game to know which mobs to skill on, I thought part of the fun of a game like this is figuring this out for yourself or with your friends.
Making it easier for people to understand how crafting works to some degree might be useful for newcomers, as it can be daunting at first, but figuring out if a mob is good for skilling, surely that's a basic of MMOs, or do we want dialogue to tell us where to go, what to kill, what to craft, where to mine and so on and so on.
Figuring out skilling is basic, and there needs to be some basic challenges left.
Zen
-
Thing is its not that hard to stand with a mob and take hits and see if your getting the avoids it should be giving regularly... if it seems a bit slow the avoids gain then stay with the same mob but move up a maturity and see if they are coming faster ...
if you run out of the maturitys and the highest of that mob isn't giving fast enough avoids gains then move to another mob that does the same avoids you want and repeat ... it isn't rocket science,its not that hard at all ... gl
I agree with Cuey, it's most definitely not rocket science.
How easy does the game need to be made, I am pretty surprised that people feel the need to have written information in game to know which mobs to skill on, I thought part of the fun of a game like this is figuring this out for yourself or with your friends.
Making it easier for people to understand how crafting works to some degree might be useful for newcomers, as it can be daunting at first, but figuring out if a mob is good for skilling, surely that's a basic of MMOs, or do we want dialogue to tell us where to go, what to kill, what to craft, where to mine and so on and so on.
Figuring out skilling is basic, and there needs to be some basic challenges left.
Zen
Agree that the quest based system that most MMOs have, has no place in AWS.
Disagree that AWS's game play is like most MMOs - hence the need for good source of info (preferably in game and maintained by DL).
-
Yeah a Zoo where we can see all mobs and find noobs like Dale and Popps i like that Idea
especialy when we can see stats to skill on that Dale creature. allthough stats would probably say awful ;D ;D ;D
and a more serious note exploring and figuring out all our selfs way more challenging and fun, after all we are here for the long term, we have been here for many years and will be for many years.
Dont make it to easy.
-
I vote for the Xen/Cuey side too. The other side i call Gimme-More-WoW-side.
I don't want my screen filled with colorful bars and tickers and numbers. That's WoW, and i hate WoW.
Too easy = Boring
Exploring the world n figuring out it's secrets = Fun
... like was in the old QA, when alarm warned us Fifth jumped the fence and killed someone.
itwasntme! :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2g5Hz17C4is (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2g5Hz17C4is)
-
Individual, a secret stays.
In 10, a secret strays.
In 1000, a secret is visible, ablaze.
-
I vote for the Xen/Cuey side too. The other side i call Gimme-More-WoW-side.I don't want my screen filled with colorful bars and tickers and numbers. That's WoW, and i hate WoW.Too easy = BoringExploring the world n figuring out it's secrets = Fun
I agree, i dont want the screen filled with colorful bars and tickers and numbers, but i dont see any problem about mouse over info like Jane said, That info only shows low % if you got hit be that mob and 100% if you killed any.
Or maybe a new equipament that do that stuff for us, and new skill like inspect mob/stuff.(i dont know if that alredy exist xD).
And last, this game is a heavy grinding game, so is normaly boring.(im not complaning)
-
Or maybe a new equipament that do that stuff for us,
actually in PE I actually enjoyed this aspect of the game. Tools to gather skill at gathering data.