AfterWorld Survival Forum

Officials => Official news => Topic started by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 09, 2015, 03:38:07 pm

Title: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 09, 2015, 03:38:07 pm
Well. Looks like I'll be the messenger that brings the bad news. Hope I'll live, though, because I have an exciting good news too.

First, BAD news. I'm sure everyone noticed that our battle with bugs after server-side update is being lost. We f*d up, in other words, and failed you - our players. What is much worse, by our estimation, with the team like ours (2 programmers) bugfixing will take 6+ months more. Then, we'll have to implement promised functionality (6+ months too) and then fix it again (about same +six months). What we have? We'll have to work for 1,5 years to make the game that we have envisioned. But due to serious crisis in Russia (in short, our programmers are earning twice less money than one month ago) we can't allow us such costy, but long development. And we have no way to hire more people, too (thanks, crisis). So, AfterWorld as it is now is getting frozen. Ooops.

But there is a GOOD news too. We have a plan, and our plan is below.

In AfterWorld, we wanted to a) implement First-Person Shooter gameplay and b)implement new characters (that we have, with tonns of weapons and really, really cool animations). But current bugs didn't allow us to work on those features. So, we are beginning work on a spin-off game 'Defense of the AfterWorld'.
In this small game that our team can handle, we are going to release those two features: new characters, FPS gameplay and few levels to run around and shoot each other, shoot creeps and destroy/defend bases. Should be fun, to have a First-Person Shooter with dota-like strategy gameplay in AfterWorld universe, with AfterWorld story.

I know what you are going to say: 'They are making YET ANOTHER GAME! Fininsh something first11!!!'. So, why we are going this way? Because we are facing three choices:

1. To close development of AfterWorld due to lack of resources (crisis, remember?);
2. To develop AfterWorld for 1,5 years more, to achieve basic game as a result that we'll have to develop until final version for yet +1,5 years - and we can't allow us to work this way anymore;
3. To make something small, but playable and fun, earn some money and return to AfterWorld MMO development.

We managed to get investments for option 3, and then we'll have to go for a Steam and Kickstarter, where we'll raise funds to continue development of both games. And this will be done simply because if we won't success, we'll have to return investments to our investor. Those are big money. And we have only 6 months to release basic version of DotAW and launch it in Steam Greenlight. But we are going all-in, to keep AfterWorld alive.

As a side effect, perhaps we'll be able to implement features from DotAW into AfterWorld (such as new characters or FPS gameplay). Also, Dale is getting a good reason to write another book.

Now, you can shoot the messenger. But I'd prefer if you wouldn't do it.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: SPECS2 "POPPS" DATA on February 09, 2015, 04:02:20 pm
Still looking for that pony
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Andrei "Andrei" Popov on February 09, 2015, 04:27:12 pm
Very upset to hear this news...  :(
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: dale "dalewj" ofj on February 09, 2015, 04:38:25 pm
and I will say,  bring back the alpha game where, get this, everything worked.  There was nothing wrong with that game, the code was decently tight and we all loved it.  Sure the graphics were old but we didn't care. 
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Andrei "Andrei" Popov on February 09, 2015, 04:48:16 pm
Quote
and I will say,  bring back the alpha game where, get this, everything worked.  There was nothing wrong with that game, the code was decently tight and we all loved it.  Sure the graphics were old but we didn't care.


Absolutely agree!!!
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Kyoraku "Shunsui" Arhitect on February 09, 2015, 05:20:46 pm
If there is any chance of getting AW Alpha back, i vote for that !




Sorry to hear this news...but this is life ! we can't get what we want always !!
All the best devs ! I really hope you'll succeed getting financed and fuck crisis !!!


Cheers !
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 09, 2015, 05:21:45 pm
I don't think bringing alpha back is possible technically. Consider this new spin-off game as a prototype for future AfterWorld gameplay, because we'll eventually blend both games into one big (and working, and stable) world. Though spin-off will stay as an independent game, most of tehnologies will be used in AfterWorld. So, we are still developing AfterWorld, though from the other end.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Scotsman "Robber" Ginger on February 09, 2015, 05:35:12 pm
Yeah Bring Alfa Back....!

P.S. its me or there is No good news?
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jonas "Druqa" Holgersson on February 09, 2015, 05:37:38 pm
My question is why are you trying to change the game so much from what it starten out as? I think i speak for most people here when i say, i would put money into alpha with no improvements for 1,5 years. And i Will put 0 dollars in for the game your making, wich is so far away from the original game.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Raynaldo "Claw" Garcia on February 09, 2015, 05:41:21 pm
What does this mean for bugfixes? Are you going to completely suspend addressing bugs while you are working on the new game? Why can't you get a kickstarter for Afterworld Survival as is?
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Scotsman "Robber" Ginger on February 09, 2015, 05:43:49 pm
What does this mean for bugfixes? Are you going to completely suspend addressing bugs while you are working on the new game? Why can't you get a kickstarter for Afterworld Survival as is?

Yeah,, I cant understand that aswell why they just dont go on Kickstarter...... is it a corporate greed to get more cash once game done... but once game done u dont need kickstarter,,,,,

well thats just my thoughts....
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Loren "Fordaetha" Silvercloak on February 09, 2015, 06:13:48 pm
I'm not sure how a dota style game is going to make you any money, you have something unique here... You don't have 10's of millions of dollars to compete with the MOBA genre
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Luc "de Belg" De vlaminck on February 09, 2015, 07:01:16 pm
Will you make this game playable first (bug fixes, ug mining, ...) or will it be abandond ?
I (and others) prefer to play this game and not the spinnoff.
So can we play and donate in this game the next year ?
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Laur "Zmeu" Coco on February 09, 2015, 07:54:37 pm
Anti,

Why don't you get a few servers to run old AWA on them (just the way it was before the AWS), and develop the new game and fix the bugs you've got in this wonderful, yet unappreciated survival?

Many, if not all the players you have now in game are craving for the old AWA.

I'm sure that it will bring you more donations and more players if you rollback to that version:

- 1st you give us a playable game not the log in-crash-log out nerve breaking game

- 2nd you listen to your fans - you are willing to admit that this was a bad move and want to correct it.

If the servers availability is the problem, I'm sure we can find a solution...

Keep the good news coming cuz we are starving for them:)

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Pila "Pila" Pila on February 09, 2015, 08:21:33 pm
If we can NOT play OLD Alpha and that isn't a possibility, can you make an Emulated Version then ?? Like the StarWarsGalaxies EMU's ?
 
Sad Sad News Indeed !!
 
(PSsst  went back to the SWGemu myself )
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton on February 09, 2015, 09:00:11 pm
First, BAD news. I'm sure everyone noticed that our battle with bugs after server-side update is being lost. We f*d up, in other words, and failed you - our players. What is much worse, by our estimation, with the team like ours (2 programmers) bugfixing will take 6+ months more. Then, we'll have to implement promised functionality (6+ months too) and then fix it again (about same +six months). What we have? We'll have to work for 1,5 years to make the game that we have envisioned. But due to serious crisis in Russia (in short, our programmers are earning twice less money than one month ago) we can't allow us such costy, but long development. And we have no way to hire more people, too (thanks, crisis). So, AfterWorld as it is now is getting frozen. Ooops.
Thank you and the AW Team for being candid with the problems and making the tough decisions that are necessary for continued (and unfortunately long-term) progress. But when you say AWR is being frozen, does that only mean no further development, bug fixing, and such will happen? If so, will we still be able to log in and advance our avatars and have at least basic support for when we get stuck?

But there is a GOOD news too. We have a plan, and our plan is below.

In AfterWorld, we wanted to a) implement First-Person Shooter gameplay and b)implement new characters (that we have, with tonns of weapons and really, really cool animations). But current bugs didn't allow us to work on those features.
Is this because the bugs are taking too long to resolve or because the bugs themselves are preventing development progress?

So, we are beginning work on a spin-off game 'Defense of the AfterWorld'.
In this small game that our team can handle, we are going to release those two features: new characters, FPS gameplay and few levels to run around and shoot each other, shoot creeps and destroy/defend bases. Should be fun, to have a First-Person Shooter with dota-like strategy gameplay in AfterWorld universe, with AfterWorld story.
So DotAW will be kind of like the Tech Demo, except that it will be fully playable? If so, I think it will be a fun distraction and could be a very good way of getting your (and AW's) name out to more gamers than just us. I've still got more avatar development that I want to do though, so I don't know how much I'll be able to really play it, just as I don't play other games right now except for a smartphone app.

I know what you are going to say: 'They are making YET ANOTHER GAME! Fininsh something first11!!!'. So, why we are going this way? Because we are facing three choices:

1. To close development of AfterWorld due to lack of resources (crisis, remember?);
2. To develop AfterWorld for 1,5 years more, to achieve basic game as a result that we'll have to develop until final version for yet +1,5 years - and we can't allow us to work this way anymore;
3. To make something small, but playable and fun, earn some money and return to AfterWorld MMO development.

We managed to get investments for option 3, and then we'll have to go for a Steam and Kickstarter, where we'll raise funds to continue development of both games. And this will be done simply because if we won't success, we'll have to return investments to our investor. Those are big money. And we have only 6 months to release basic version of DotAW and launch it in Steam Greenlight. But we are going all-in, to keep AfterWorld alive.
It's good to hear that you have investment funds for SOMEthing, but will it be released only through Steam and not directly like AWR?

As a side effect, perhaps we'll be able to implement features from DotAW into AfterWorld (such as new characters or FPS gameplay). Also, Dale is getting a good reason to write another book.

Now, you can shoot the messenger. But I'd prefer if you wouldn't do it.
As I read from the top I had hoped you would end with this, but what kind of time frame are you expecting until such features will be available in AWR? And what kind of time frame until all features are fully merged from DotAW to AWR? Do you think that there will be some new DotAW features that won't make sense to bring into AWR or are all DotAW features being planned for both games?

Thanks as always for the update and I hope you will take the time to address each of the questions I've posed. All of them are very important and the answers may determine whether or not I stick with the AW universe or switch to another one, which would make me quite sad.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Hugo "Lossehelin" Santos on February 09, 2015, 09:10:01 pm
hum... don't really know what to say about this. You are going to try to make a "small" game in the moba genre which is already overcrowded to get some money to continue this game....... yeah... i got nothing....
Explain me again, why doing a kickstarter now is not possible? You need more developers obviously, we know that since the beginning, you have a product to show on kickstarter, so why not? is it because your are in russia? im susre there are ways to walk around that..,
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Sifalio "Sifis" Kritikakis on February 09, 2015, 10:19:37 pm

Thank you for letting us know Anti.

I am on the "BRING THE AWA BACK" supporters side!!!


Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Cobra "The Guru" Guru on February 09, 2015, 11:40:07 pm
I don't like and don't play moba games so I'll probably leave AW community if there is no other options.

sad to hear  :-\
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Tuman "Tuman" Tuman Altay on February 10, 2015, 01:59:22 am
Anti, you fail same as like Bank !!!
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Serenity "SerenityFireFly" FireFly on February 10, 2015, 03:45:28 am
Hi,
My opinion is bring AWA back (alpha) then make a new  game,  make alpha  back to what it was before AWS, we can do noobot runs  then,  an continue picking in quaranteen  hunting skilling an having fun gaming then when  time comes survival is ready update the inventory content from awa to  aws and skills etc an let people play aws then, to be completely honest i miss alpha i miss the old zones kamchatsk  lugansk tl1 loD  a1  sar zones  etc it was fun  running about changing between zones, for alpha players could sit happily enjoying an donateing to a game to play while at the same point it was  before survival was released an  players wouldnt be bothered about the update on survival because there would be something to play or do that was stable, to make another game an get it to the point alpha was isn't that good im all for DL games an afterworld. but for me id prefer to have alpha  back stable an playable  in a game we know and lovee and adore that made us want to log in grind run about shoot an have fun in then start completely over.

Love AWA alot!, Love AWS some, its getting there, another game? i'd rather be with what we now then  a game we dont know.. bringing AWA back wouldnt be a mistake or  accepting defeat it would be helping the  player base to grow in a steady enviroment, yeah graphics  is dated some but you know what.. i think we all fell in love with those  graphics to begin with.  i wish AWS the best, But i will forever be a fan of AWA and DL work, not looking to join another game when it takes time away from AWS or AWA. AWA was stable reliable an virtually bug free,  bringing it back would help the community, we could  bot hunt do community events and help others joining whilst devs focused on AWS  taking income from AWA because we dont expect AWA to be updated again or improved. i think AWA would be great way to fund AWS.  or even AWA  renamed  to afterworld before birth or something  cheesy like that:) love aw hope to see it back *hugs*

*cheers for AWA*
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Event "Janе" Horizon on February 10, 2015, 05:39:32 am
Sometimes a reality check is required.

It has been fairly obvious for many, many months that the development was going nowhere due to to team and experience issues. The development plan has always been too ambitious for the team capabilities.

Obviously bringing back AWA is not possible as this would not be the showcase game that Dedicated Logic needs to impress new investors.

How a small shoot-em-up game will generate income will be an interesting question.

Why Kickstarter would want to fund both a disposable game and a game that is 18-24 months from being ready, where the controlling company has already shown that they are unable to deliver, is another interesting question.

Dedicated Logic need to learn to deliver. This means a change in scope of what they are attempting - small iterative, achievable, incremental changes - instead of trying to overreach their capabilities.

Until Dedicated Logic start behaving like a game development company and stop wasting time on things that they cannot achieve and start developing in short sprints instead of day dreaming about what they will deliver in several years time, Dedicated Logic will continue to find themselves underachieving.

I doubt if any of our comments will make a difference. The problems within Dedicated Logic would have been apparent for many years now. And ignored or at least not resolved.

Sorry for any hurt feelings.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Gebeleizis "Hultaan" Kapnobatai on February 10, 2015, 06:43:19 am
hey all,

what I see is

-the 100k just gone and the single , and only purpose those 100k supposed to have meaning to make the servers clustering work just failed
-the game is in a bug state that any other main activity except sitting in one place isn't working and I m saying , no mining, no picking, no hunting, no tutorials, no taming, no training, no LoD
-the few months of something has turned into few other months extra till 1 year
-the one bad bug "the wave" we had is now the loot unbalanced, mob disappearing, mining impossible, partial trading,

what I m thinking/wondering is

-if , today I ask a neutral company to deliver me in 4 months (start of June) a Torque3D bug fix cluster balanced platform, from what we have now, is possible to be achieved for the sum of 100k US?....I m asking this seriously as a business man, cause sometimes is better to supervise something u buy than work on it for a long time, because the final goal was to provide something not to get a broken neck. ( maybe I m wrong here not my area, just fishing )

what I would do is

-implement AWS-308 tomorrow whit the new city, new character, new guns, everything I want to put in the other small game, everything on, if is bugged let it be bugged all, why to be a continuous bugged re bugged and forever bugged feeling, once for good, and this way I can see how is going to be , not wishes, it is as it is. period
-create inside the game, an instant or, a tunnel to a LoD loading perfectly and there to be the PvP-FPS platform u want, but allow the new players to see the game as it is whit all the necessary work to be finished, this way they can travel, and see where the money will go, everyone can log into AWS travel from one side to another, skill if they want to skill, explore, and then from every major city they can use the teleporter to go inside LoD FPS PvP to play, and all this new feature I create can be part of the future game, until I find a better purpose of it. WHAT U HAVE TO LOSE? nothing, then start to release the features who are already done.
- start the damn kickstarter, just start it, what the heck is better to create a second game time eating and the idea same team si working on something different to gather investment for another game? or to present a well advertised gameinfo that allow everyone to see where did this game get all over the years , where to go, what is next goal, and how much money is needed?
-if a timeframe is announced, keep your word no matter what, ppl and investors don't see anything except excuses, they don't understand the complexity of the issues, are just words, this is on u, as a DEVS team, u better say a bit later than earlier an not to meet the time.
-I would bet on the game community more than the political boundaries, the gaming is different than government political agenda, and if the kickstarter is released, I believe the world would vote to support a team from Russia who is working on something unique such this game, and I doubt the other way to create a second game is better than this, in my opinion starting the kickstarter now is the beast advantage this game could have, just because of the crisis u are allowed to start before u finished the tutorial and server issues, this is a reason to be exploited , so do 'it, .... an American story where a world crisis hit the team who started to develop a game whit such cool features and bla bla... is sealable
-this game is a business tho, so act like a business company, find what's beast and meet the requirements.

what I know

-this game is one of the beast, cool and great idea of gaming I know, I like Project Entropia v much, but when comes about AWS I can say the potential of this is crazy and I like it more
-AWS is not dead, just need a bit of luck, and few more courage from DL team.
- I know this post doesn't count, because I see some things while DL see other things and they think like Eastern, sad to say this but is my personal feeling

cheers
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: oOoOo "Mantra" oOoOo on February 10, 2015, 07:30:36 am
Is the alpha version up for sale? This could rise good money for the spin-off game development.

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Skaarj "Skaarj" Skaarj on February 10, 2015, 07:34:08 am
Тоже за то чтоб Альфа версию вернули!!
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 10, 2015, 08:42:06 am
My question is why are you trying to change the game so much from what it starten out as? I think i speak for most people here when i say, i would put money into alpha with no improvements for 1,5 years. And i Will put 0 dollars in for the game your making, wich is so far away from the original game.


Becuase there are just few jedi's like you are in the world, and we are in debt for several hundred dollars that we have to return. On alpha gameplay we won't be able to make it - and previous profits (tiny, even in the best time of alpha) woldn't be enough. We either have to close the company and declare bankruptcy, or do something modern and actual for majority of the players in the world. If you believe it's an easy decision, you are wrong - easy would be close development right now and say bye-bye to your and our dreams.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 10, 2015, 08:45:25 am
What does this mean for bugfixes? Are you going to completely suspend addressing bugs while you are working on the new game? Why can't you get a kickstarter for Afterworld Survival as is?

Yeah,, I cant understand that aswell why they just dont go on Kickstarter...... is it a corporate greed to get more cash once game done... but once game done u dont need kickstarter,,,,,

well thats just my thoughts....


Because we a) game as it is won't rais enough funds (if collect anything at all), and b) we can't bring backers to the game in such condition, nor we have guarantee to finish it in time. Currently, Kickstarter is not an option, or we would go that way.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 10, 2015, 08:49:13 am
Will you make this game playable first (bug fixes, ug mining, ...) or will it be abandond ?
I (and others) prefer to play this game and not the spinnoff.
So can we play and donate in this game the next year ?


Perhaps I wasn't clear in the first post.

We can't bring you stable and interesting game (that also would bring us any money and allow us to continue development) in nearly future. It would require one more year of investments, and we don't have them (thanks to the crisis). And players can't play in AWR with current level of (low) stability and those frequent crashes.

This game will stay live and perhaps features from DotAW will be implemented to AWR, but we won't spend time on bugfixing until DotAW is finished.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 10, 2015, 08:59:57 am
But when you say AWR is being frozen, does that only mean no further development, bug fixing, and such will happen? If so, will we still be able to log in and advance our avatars and have at least basic support for when we get stuck?
Game will still operate, but we can't promise anything. Releasing stuck people - yes, I'm pretty sure it will happen.

Is this because the bugs are taking too long to resolve or because the bugs themselves are preventing development progress?

Both, unfortunately. We can't move forward until those bugs are fixed, and we can't fix them quick enough while there are just two coders are working on the project.

So DotAW will be kind of like the Tech Demo, except that it will be fully playable? If so, I think it will be a fun distraction and could be a very good way of getting your (and AW's) name out to more gamers than just us. I've still got more avatar development that I want to do though, so I don't know how much I'll be able to really play it, just as I don't play other games right now except for a smartphone app.



Yes, very much like so. We'll release new gameplay that we wanted to release in AWR and test/tune it on DotAW; We'll release smarter AI and build foundation for future corporation wars, and we'll release new avatars, with new animations. All those features, if everything will go well, will be then integrated into AWR. If/when we'll raise funds on Steam or Kickstarter, we'll also be able to hire more ciders and finish bugfixing, to make AWR stable.

It's good to hear that you have investment funds for SOMEthing, but will it be released only through Steam and not directly like AWR?



Pretty sure we'll make both ways to play the game.

As I read from the top I had hoped you would end with this, but what kind of time frame are you expecting until such features will be available in AWR? And what kind of time frame until all features are fully merged from DotAW to AWR? Do you think that there will be some new DotAW features that won't make sense to bring into AWR or are all DotAW features being planned for both games?


I've no idea. And of course many things (like simplified skill system) won't be merged to AWR. Only those features that are useful for AWR and makes sense will be used.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 10, 2015, 09:05:44 am
-if , today I ask a neutral company to deliver me in 4 months (start of June) a Torque3D bug fix cluster balanced platform, from what we have now, is possible to be achieved for the sum of 100k US?....I m asking this seriously as a business man, cause sometimes is better to supervise something u buy than work on it for a long time, because the final goal was to provide something not to get a broken neck. ( maybe I m wrong here not my area, just fishing )



100k US would give us time to finish bugfixing in next 6 months (not less), but there won't be any new content/features. Just stable AWR, without crashes/charaters stucking and with polished loot balance. So everything you wrote below 'what would I do...' isn't fitting into those 6 months and $100k, or we would go that route.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Cattevion "Azhela" Xanovents on February 10, 2015, 12:41:42 pm
yes i know you in a hard time...
and yes it's wise to choosing option 3 to make some "back-up" for AW...
"To make something small, but playable and fun, earn some money and return to AfterWorld MMO development"
and to making a plan like..
a) implement First-Person Shooter gameplay...?
and than what..?
---no,no, no, im not starting to make any debate or anything like that---
-but, it not gonna work "because is just like the other game"
(people will start thinking "ah this game is not fair, the F im gonna survive look at those damage" and this and that and yes they will leave after that)
-im just wanted to say : "we need bigger than that"
something that can bring people together
something that a master and newbie are needed each other
something that "i wanna do my best to protect our people"
something that "i miss my friend on this game"
-yes people this day need more challenge too
so why we dont make a
- League -  for those people who really seek a glorious "TEAM" name
- Corporation - for those people who wanted to become a "KING amongst KINGS"
- and for those a new comer for game can start working with those people
-and yes PVP,PVE, or event maybe a "WorldVsWorld" are still exist , dont change that
so it will become easy, fun,enjoyable and hard long journey to achieve that..

--im just share my opinion though, really--
i just wanted this game is simple and best game it ever exist :)
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Raynaldo "Claw" Garcia on February 10, 2015, 01:53:43 pm
Have you considered getting your company on the public market? You know, let people buy shares.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Richard "Snakeeyes11" Walsh on February 10, 2015, 06:46:52 pm
Tragic post,


I'm not quite sure of the business sense the attempt to create another smaller game makes?


I'm not sure how old my character is (5 years? more ? less?). However, from the from the first time I logged in after becoming disillusioned with entropia/universe/project entropia/planet calypso/whatever they call it nowadays I like hultaan saw the massive potential of this RCE. It had/has a far more sophisticated crafting system which gives the foundation for a REAL rce and not a casino which everything else would feed into (hunting and mining for materials). It's been heartbreaking to see it continually go backwards. There are many talented players that play this game and in my belief would be able to add massive value and potential. I haven't seen any financials but I wouldn't be surprised that the Alpha days had more deposits than the survival days. There just is less and less reason for people to do so.


As I mentioned before there are plenty of talented people both in business and skillset that could provide help to move this game forward.


This is what i've gleaned whilst playing and scouring the forums


Jane Event Horizon - Understands Quality Assurance. Especially in a game environment setting
Hultaan - Has a very sound business mind
Dale - on a par with hultaan from a business perspective but also understands systems and back end infrastructure


I could name many more extolling particular values. [size=78%]I think Dedicated Logic could do worse than embracing the community getting them involved and utilising such knowledge and expertise.[/size]

I believe that the following needs to be understood (I understand you probably won't answer these)


1) How much does it cost every month to keep the lights on?
2) How much does it cost every month to actively work on the project as is? Whether it's bug fixing of feature development.


I wouldn't be surprised that a core group of die hard players and supporters would be willing to commit a set amount of money per month to the continued development of this project through donations so long as there is a clear roadmap and an understanding of priorities and milestones.


I for one would be willing to donate $200 to $300 each and every month even if I have an awd balance if I knew that it was being used to help the greater good and am pretty sure a lot of the other core players of this game would do the same so long as there is a clear roadmap with milestones that are driven towards etc.
 
I honestly believe that this game has a stronger foundation than the other more successful one and could have had such a player base itself…
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton on February 10, 2015, 08:43:03 pm
Thanks for your replies Anti, you have given us a lot more information and what I believe is strong enough reasoning to go the route you've "chosen" (which actually seems to be a course you're being forced into.)

...we are in debt for several hundred {thousand?} dollars that we have to return. On alpha gameplay we won't be able to make it - and previous profits (tiny, even in the best time of alpha) woldn't be enough.
I've added the part in curly braces {} because I'm sure that a matter of several hundred dollars would not cause such drastic changes in their plans. This is a huge point that I didn't know about and I think many people did not pay enough attention to.

The bottom line is that they not only need to continue paying the bills to keep the lights on and the team fed, but also to pay back their debts. This is one of the big potential downsides of outside investors - some will want results faster or bigger than what can actually be delivered and will want their money back. Of course, this could have just been a business loan from a bank or something, but the result is the same. They would probably need lots of people donating $200-$300 per month and it's clear that many of us play AW (at least in part) because it is free and we cannot afford to pay a monthly fee of any kind, let alone $200.

There just aren't enough of us to be able to provide the funds that they need, so they need more players. Getting more players requires a more stable game with more features because of the many, many competing games (though none are as cool or as fun, IMHO) that are more stable, feature-rich, and free to play. I'm sure that Anti is fully aware of what the team's capabilities are and how quickly they can make progress, so I believe the time frames he's given for getting AWR up to par are pretty accurate. That's a long time to wait until they're able to draw the number of additional players they'd need to get the additional funding they require and there's no way that anyone who is owed six figures will wait that long for repayment.

So Anti, my next question is how confident are you in your team's ability to stand up a new game based on the existing assets and systems in a relatively quick time? You're obviously confident enough to try it rather than closing the doors completely on AW, but do you sure that you can release this new game within the six month deadline?
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Richard "Snakeeyes11" Walsh on February 10, 2015, 09:07:22 pm
All valid points. However, if the debts do run into several hundred thousand dollars then they may as well turn the servers off now. It won't be possible to turn that around.


That being said of course it takes many people depositing $200 to $300 to potentially turn things around. However, I think you'd probably be surprised at the number of people in game that could put in that sort of investment. Although that is of course unlikely still to be enough to help. Without knowledge of the underlying costs involved we'll never truly know.


I'd also disagree with the statement


Quote
[size=0px]I'm sure that Anti is fully aware of what the team's capabilities are and how quickly they can make progress, so I believe the time frames he's given for getting AWR up to par are pretty accurate.[/size]




It may sound harsh and a bit of a bashing but the reality is facts speak louder than anything and there's nothing that's happened in the past couple of years that suggests this statement to be true.

Anyways the point i'm making is the dev team is still the same and is committing to yet another game that would have be developed and released with no guarantee of a higher take up than the current one. Yet the current one could be driven forward by the current player base at no cost to dedicated logic with right program manager and tools in place to do so.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: oOoOo "Mantra" oOoOo on February 10, 2015, 09:46:38 pm
If not intend to sell the alpha version, and not want to throw 10 years of development out of the window, than do a favor for your playerbase.

Make the last backup of alpha open-source.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Hugo "Lossehelin" Santos on February 10, 2015, 10:41:31 pm
well anti, the decision has been made and you guys are going ahead with dotaWR (i would change the as valve would come and destroy you).
My little advice is: turn off the servers. save the money to help the development until you have something to show...... or... at least turn off new registrations.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Event "Janе" Horizon on February 11, 2015, 12:03:55 am
Regarding players 'investing' money in the game.
Players that are serious about this - use the Donations (https://my.afterworld.deelogic.net/survival/index.php?action=treasury) option  ::)

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 11, 2015, 04:08:56 pm
Thanks for your replies Anti, you have given us a lot more information and what I believe is strong enough reasoning to go the route you've "chosen" (which actually seems to be a course you're being forced into.)

...we are in debt for several hundred {thousand?} dollars that we have to return. On alpha gameplay we won't be able to make it - and previous profits (tiny, even in the best time of alpha) woldn't be enough.
I've added the part in curly braces {} because I'm sure that a matter of several hundred dollars would not cause such drastic changes in their plans. This is a huge point that I didn't know about and I think many people did not pay enough attention to.


My bad. If course thousands, and it's not tens of thousands, more.

I'll reply in details to other posts (some are really really good and touching) tomorrow.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 11, 2015, 04:19:37 pm
That being said of course it takes many people depositing $200 to $300 to potentially turn things around. However, I think you'd probably be surprised at the number of people in game that could put in that sort of investment. Although that is of course unlikely still to be enough to help. Without knowledge of the underlying costs involved we'll never truly know.


Quote
[size=0px]I'm sure that Anti is fully aware of what the team's capabilities are and how quickly they can make progress, so I believe the time frames he's given for getting AWR up to par are pretty accurate.[/size]
It may sound harsh and a bit of a bashing but the reality is facts speak louder than anything and there's nothing that's happened in the past couple of years that suggests this statement to be true.

Anyways the point i'm making is the dev team is still the same and is committing to yet another game that would have be developed and released with no guarantee of a higher take up than the current one. Yet the current one could be driven forward by the current player base at no cost to dedicated logic with right program manager and tools in place to do so.


This is absolutely correct, and this is why option "ask players for donation and continue development of AWR" isn't acceptable. We won't go for such commitments, knowing our unability to provide guaranteed development milestones, especially if players will donate money and expect our developers to do it in time.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 11, 2015, 04:35:15 pm
So Anti, my next question is how confident are you in your team's ability to stand up a new game based on the existing assets and systems in a relatively quick time? You're obviously confident enough to try it rather than closing the doors completely on AW, but do you sure that you can release this new game within the six month deadline?


I don't know. But I believe in AfterWorld and our developers. Also I believe and AfterWorld won't just disappear - fate of this game is different.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Event "Janе" Horizon on February 11, 2015, 08:06:22 pm
Hi Anti,

I assume that the DL team is now fully allocated to "Defense of the AfterWorld" (note: that title does not need 'the' in there. Or you could call it 'Afterworld: Defense" or  'Afterworld Defense Force').

So, what about Survival - should this remain up and available to players? This consumes valuable DL team time - assuming the team will continue to resolve account problems and other player issues.

At the very least, the registration page needs to be taken down (my.afterworld.ru). This can be replaced with the appropriate new game registration page at a later stage.

The Survival home page (www.afterworld.ru (http://www.afterworld.ru)) should be updated to reflect the new direction, the Survival download link removed.

Perhaps a home page redesign - drum up anticipation of the new game ... "Coming soon to a PC near you! Defense of AfterWorld!!". Then later once Survival is in-scope again, add a more modern looking enticement to download Survival.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Zaelkaer "Allfather" Vampyre on February 12, 2015, 07:33:23 am
My Suggestion:

you're trying to fix a whole world - fix a SMALL piece of land that has a little bit of everything working. that way i guarantee you the whole playerbase will be active to be able to skill and hunt and stuff. even if its small amounts of mob, everyone will then be happy to wait until the distant future when the game might be ready because then people can Progress their avatar

Just NU and Sar, and place all mob types around the perimeter of Sar
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Rebel Leader "Madseend" Troubles on February 12, 2015, 08:15:27 am

My Suggestion:

you're trying to fix a whole world - fix a SMALL piece of land that has a little bit of everything working. that way i guarantee you the whole playerbase will be active to be able to skill and hunt and stuff. even if its small amounts of mob, everyone will then be happy to wait until the distant future when the game might be ready because then people can Progress their avatar

Just NU and Sar, and place all mob types around the perimeter of Sar
I like this idea or @least turn up the loot abit and give us some water in loot.
and put officers back in swamp :D






Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Event "Janе" Horizon on February 12, 2015, 08:47:46 am

My Suggestion:

you're trying to fix a whole world - fix a SMALL piece of land that has a little bit of everything working. that way i guarantee you the whole playerbase will be active to be able to skill and hunt and stuff. even if its small amounts of mob, everyone will then be happy to wait until the distant future when the game might be ready because then people can Progress their avatar

Just NU and Sar, and place all mob types around the perimeter of Sar
I like this idea or @least turn up the loot abit and give us some water in loot.
and put officers back in swamp :D
It is not about  making us happy nor is it about  letting us progress in the AWS.
We are irrelevant.

It is about making money.
AWS cannot provide this. It is too broken to host the horde that Dedicated Logic dreams about.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Nathan "Naro D" Richmond on February 12, 2015, 02:58:20 pm
It happens i feel sad.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Serenity "SerenityFireFly" FireFly on February 13, 2015, 09:02:13 am
All i can say is those players (myself included) in alpha and aws when we had stable game play decent mobs to hunt we  paid in to craft our geat an hunt more it was a style burn the awd to gear to skills to getting loot an repeat, people paid for up untill a recent  update mobs were pretty  stable in aws  same with  being able to rock pick or get loot etc its only the recent changes that  made it more buggy things that should have been in taming,  bots to hunt, UG Mining, mobs put in with loot on leave the borders an seperating places off an these refreshes that are  causes crashes.. if aws had the time it took to make a new game you would have the  playerbase back an donating, thats all we are waiting for to be able to run not crash or be bugged to be able to hunt mine an do the game acivities we are used to doing, i dont think the other game will bring income but i know before  aws in alpha  people grinded there way through the game  either traded to get awd or bought awd, it is possible. even if sat there an said ok we go 8 hours a  week on bug fix an  then updated the  game an let community know that theres fixes old players would come back newer ones would, an your playerbase would then go to other game  sites an bring others into game aswell better  graphics or stuff thatw as planned isnt as  important as making it functional if it were me id opt to spend x amount of time to fix stuff then do other game. AWS isnt  making  money off because its been buggy an unplayable for some for a while. i wish devs could see what actually made money for them is AW working not another game.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Te "Te Aroha" Aroha on February 13, 2015, 10:45:31 am
I was very sad to read the post about Survival development to not be continued due to lack of funds.


Sadly I think that this is the end for AW as we know it. Any new game would have to be something very special to create the amount of money needed to continue this project and I can't see that happening any time soon or even anytime in the next two years.


Thanks for all your hard work on the project Anti you brought us hope but it was not possible to bring a stable playable game to the market.

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: SPECS2 "POPPS" DATA on February 13, 2015, 11:48:52 am
THX SFF, you did this. its your fault , see what your actions lead to. We had nice game, things did work then YOU harassed every player to leave Now see how many lives you messed up THX
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Paul "Cuey" Darkmane on February 13, 2015, 12:47:08 pm
THX SFF, you did this. its your fault , see what your actions lead to. We had nice game, things did work then YOU harassed every player to leave Now see how many lives you messed up THX

That's not true at all about SFF POPPS, how long has AWS been here for now ?, 2 years+? and there has been peace in the game all this time and on the forum... its not ANY players fault that dedicated Logic has come to this decision about AWS ... i still have faith AWS has a future and there is no use to point fingers.

Iv not had a say on this thread yet,so IMO AWS was working well (hunting,mining,crafting etc) up until the point of the update when they tried to add the new server borders, i understand they were needed for future expansion of the world but things worked well mostly up until that point,on that update,that's what i remember.


Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: SPECS2 "POPPS" DATA on February 13, 2015, 01:32:01 pm
AWS had to find investors because they lost there player base !!!!to bad we don't have all the deleted post in this forum from years ago. think hate mail for her was half of forum.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 13, 2015, 01:44:14 pm
There are no one guilty amongst players in the situation. Developers are mature people who can make thier own decisions. So don't blame SFF, blame only us if you want to do so.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Hugo "Lossehelin" Santos on February 13, 2015, 05:08:55 pm
What does this mean for bugfixes? Are you going to completely suspend addressing bugs while you are working on the new game? Why can't you get a kickstarter for Afterworld Survival as is?

Yeah,, I cant understand that aswell why they just dont go on Kickstarter...... is it a corporate greed to get more cash once game done... but once game done u dont need kickstarter,,,,,

well thats just my thoughts....


Because we a) game as it is won't rais enough funds (if collect anything at all), and b) we can't bring backers to the game in such condition, nor we have guarantee to finish it in time. Currently, Kickstarter is not an option, or we would go that way.

SOrry anti but i fail to see your point.
You have a good concept of game, a good game. You can show the game on kickstarter. You can show the potential of the game. If you fail to raise enough money they fine, at least your tried. But what if you can raise enough money on kickstarter?
I see games on kickstarter that don't have much to show but still are successful....

I don't know, but maybe i just fail to understand it.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Caliopus "Calio" Jones on February 13, 2015, 11:00:19 pm
I'm not a pessimist by nature, but I've been thinking about this since Anti's post and I'm sorry, I just don't see how this plan can end well. 
 
AWS/AWR is one of only 2 (3 if one counts SL as a 'game') fleshed out RCE games out there.  Yes, there are money problems, but if DL can somehow push through they will have the others beat by a mile and pull in players.
 
But, putting AWS/AWR on hold spells a slow death as the few remaining players drift away for lack of resources (e.g., water to make HKs and no UG resources coming into game and no players around to buy them from).  DL might as well shut down the servers now and conserve its cash.
 
On the other hand, the planned MOBA will be just one of many MOBAs, many of which are well integrated into larger fully polished FTP games, and I can't see why players would: 1) play the one DL is planning on making (how is it better? what's the draw?), and 2) pay for the ability to play it. 
 
So, while AWS/AWR withers away, what little funds are/become available get invested in a something that won't generate the funds to save it.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Asterion "Zort" Wrynn on February 14, 2015, 09:48:24 am

I am very disappointed but I am not surprised by this bad news.


Several people around me had announced the death of AWS.


We waited an update regarding balancing loot and bug fixes. We had an update that went wrong effected. Objects were missing after this update. It was noted the professionalism of the team AWS.


This should not be too difficult to extract the data in XML, to work on it and then re-inject the same data.


In conclusion it was always the same problem, the organization of work and delays that are not required.


You have a great gaming platform and with correct graphics. We simply lack the content, RCE (input / output) and the organization.


If you want to abandon AWS (that's what I understand), change the code as open source. We will get a fix bugs and make it evolve. Because there are people with very good skills in the player base.


For my part, I have more than 20 years developing experiences. And it seems that you still refuse External aid. Which I think was a mistake.


I wish you good luck for your next project.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: oOoOo "Mantra" oOoOo on February 14, 2015, 11:41:02 am
If you want to abandon AWS (that's what I understand), change the code as open source. We will get a fix bugs and make it evolve. Because there are people with very good skills in the player base.

This is exatcly what i suggested earlier. Or sell the project.

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Turpov "Turpov Flytest" Flytest on February 14, 2015, 03:04:30 pm
100 k Dollars ? Oo
its crisis in Russia ?
So crisis + 100 K dollars = lot of money to develop a game

with 100 K dollars you can create 100 % a game, a movie, buy a company, paid 10 developers for 2 years......
I dont understand why you need this amount of dollars

and i dont understand the decision to stop a game when you have some players/investissor , players who are ready to repair bugs...

AW had a nice storyline and cyberpunk atmosphère ...but its your game and your decision
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Hugo "Lossehelin" Santos on February 14, 2015, 03:12:09 pm
10 developers for 2 years? yeah if they are indian or philipino :p
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: dale "dalewj" ofj on February 14, 2015, 03:32:27 pm
well 100K ruble is only $1500 Us.  so I expect your talking US$.

and $100 barely gets u 3 people for a year.  2 more like it.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Vladislav "Spiker" Ogir on February 14, 2015, 03:34:50 pm
I guess the DotaAW will be similar to league of legends, except with a hint of AfterWorld with an FPS mode?


It could be quite exciting like a quite exciting game, potentially, depending on how it will come out.


Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Vladislav "Spiker" Ogir on February 14, 2015, 03:36:33 pm
well 100K ruble is only $1500 Us.  so I expect your talking US$.

and $100 barely gets u 3 people for a year.  2 more like it.


In UK $100k would get you 2 junior developers for 1 year. (that is including all the business costs that comes with hiring full time staff)
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Hugo "Lossehelin" Santos on February 14, 2015, 05:48:33 pm
Just a few examples on kickstarter:

Exploding kittens:
Goal of $10000... they got $6 million!!!! Ok, it is a game of kittens.... because. kittens,... you know lol
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category)

Star Mazerr
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular)
Goal: $160k, 7 days to go and they have $126k

Wasteland 2
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded)
Goal:  $900k, they got: $2.9M

Kingdom Come: Deliverance
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance)
Goal: 300k, they got $1.1M

ShadowRun: Hong Kong.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong)
Ok they have had other projects that may help him. They have a good number in their team but still they only asked for 100k and got 976k!
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: karl "oele" maier on February 14, 2015, 07:29:36 pm
Just wanted to add my 2 cents .. not that I think it makes any difference.
I do believe that AWS has a future .. maybe just needs a different start .. but not with a shooting game .. they are a dime a dozend. It is the market / char. development part what brought people to it ..and kept them here. There is another game i would like you to check out Anti .. not for the game as such but how it gets developed. Its called " Star Citizen". Just like AWS it offers a unique play experience and it is completely crowd/backer funded ( think the amount of funding is now around 70 mill.) The game parts which are currently available where brought out in bits and pieces to the backers ( no public play as such ) for testing . Maybe that would be a way to keep going or to restart. As they say .. you have to learn to crawl before you can run .

Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Gebeleizis "Hultaan" Kapnobatai on February 15, 2015, 05:49:40 am
Just a few examples on kickstarter:

Exploding kittens:
Goal of $10000... they got $6 million!!!! Ok, it is a game of kittens.... because. kittens,... you know lol
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category)

Star Mazerr
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular)
Goal: $160k, 7 days to go and they have $126k

Wasteland 2
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded)
Goal:  $900k, they got: $2.9M

Kingdom Come: Deliverance
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance)
Goal: 300k, they got $1.1M

ShadowRun: Hong Kong.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong)
Ok they have had other projects that may help him. They have a good number in their team but still they only asked for 100k and got 976k!



see that's what I said earlier, and I do believe is beast way no matter what, is what I would advice anyone to do..

1.implement all features u have ready, bugged or not bugged, this way we few players can do small video whit the game and post on youtube or whatever.(anyhow we'r not do much atm in game)
2.is better to use AWS as a platform of the features u want to be seen, not other game, in my opinion, no matter what u add extra, the original should look same, not a " wish to be like "
3.if stupid lame games got funds, I trust the gaming market will provide hundreds of ppl to support an RCE in development gave, unique, and v rare these days .
4.this would be the business card for you, what I have... what I need, where I m.....and where I want to go.
5.No BS, just the pure truth, and the truth will set u free.

cheers
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Event "Janе" Horizon on February 15, 2015, 08:14:10 am
Telling Dedicated Logic how to fund their game has never worked in the past, and it is unlikely that it will work this time.

Strangers giving advice about an problem, that they have no inside knowledge of, is like strangers giving advice about a marriage in crisis - better ignored than useful.

We have no insight into the internal politics, the company goals, the real issues and challenges they are facing nor the team dynamics driving this change.

We have only one thing we can do to help - wait for another 6 - 8 months for the showcase game to be released.
No doubt Dedicated Logic will need our help testing the new independent game - the more polished this is, the more likely that their goals will be met.



I personally will be keeping an eye on this forum with the intent of helping out Dedicated Logic with my invaluable time if I am able.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton on February 15, 2015, 08:31:01 am
Just a few notes on the games that Hugo pointed out:
Exploding kittens:
Goal of $10000... they got $6 million!!!! Ok, it is a game of kittens.... because. kittens,... you know lol
[url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category[/url] ([url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kittens?ref=category[/url])
This game not only has kittens (which we all know that the Internet regularly goes ape nuts over, haha), but the world-renowned comic humor of The Oatmeal, who has a massive fan base. I didn't know he was connected to any game creation, but I'm not at all surprised that the game's goal was obliterated. This guy is pretty damn hilarious and if you haven't seen it yet, check out http://theoatmeal.com/ (http://theoatmeal.com/) for a whole mess of funny ways to waste your time!

Star Mazerr
[url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular[/url] ([url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/imagosfilms/starr-mazer?ref=category_popular[/url])
Goal: $160k, 7 days to go and they have $126k
This one looks entertaining enough and it grabs the attention of anyone looking for retro-styled games (which is another good-sized crowd). Plus it was given a "Kick Starter Staff Pick," which raises its profile by a good bit.

Wasteland 2
[url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded[/url] ([url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2?ref=category_most_funded[/url])
Goal:  $900k, they got: $2.9M
Wasteland 2 is the sequel to the classic, late-80s RPG that inspired the first Fallout games. 'Nuf said.

Kingdom Come: Deliverance
[url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance[/url] ([url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1294225970/kingdom-come-deliverance[/url])
Goal: 300k, they got $1.1M
This one looks really good, with lots of innovative features and capabilities that weren't possible in the past, in a game using CryEngine to make an absolutely gorgeous game. The dev team includes people who worked on Mafia, Mafia II, Operation Flashpoint: Cold War Crisis, Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising, ARMA: Armed Assault, and UFO: Aftershock.

ShadowRun: Hong Kong.
[url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong[/url] ([url]https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/webeharebrained/shadowrun-hong-kong[/url])
Ok they have had other projects that may help him. They have a good number in their team but still they only asked for 100k and got 976k!
With 58 hours to go, this game is now fully funded and as you point out, it's part of a series that has done well in the past.

So all of the examples you've given are for games where someone or something is well known and loved. These are projects that were almost certainly going to be funded because of the sheer number of gamers with positive memories playing these groups' previous games. AW does not have that benefit (that we know of).


I don't mean to imply that AW won't have any success with a Kickstarter at this stage, just that it will be harder than it was for all of your examples. On the other hand, AW is a game that anyone can download and play for free, right now, so it does have a very good leg up on the competition. Most Kickstarters for game projects have a pretty long lead time, requiring backers to wait a year or more until they actually get to see anything for their backing funds, but AW has another leg up on the competition in being able to give backer rewards much more quickly. But without plenty of reading or lots of play time, it's hard to get a good feel for why AW is so great and why so many of us stick around, which is why a very good Kickstarter project page is needed. In the end, I think that it really can't hurt for the devs to try for a Kickstarter right now, asking for the money they need to get everything fixed within the next twelve months, even if that means hiring another 2-4 devs. If the AW Team focuses the next month on producing a fantastic Kickstarter page to demonstrate and explain what makes AW worth their money, I think it is a much better use of time and energy than working on a new (though related) game and hoping for enough purchases on a platform that has over 4400 games (http://www.gaugepowered.com/browse/) to choose from, not to mention the fact that DotAW would seem to compete directly with Steam's top-played game (http://store.steampowered.com/stats/), which was developed by the same team that created Steam in the first place, Valve (http://www.valvesoftware.com/games/).


On the other hand, it's true that the AW Team seems to make their decisions and stick to them. Obviously they know the situation better than we do by a long shot, but we might be able to open their eyes to new ideas or new ways of seeing existing ideas.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Dark "Benek" Hunter on February 15, 2015, 12:28:46 pm
If this game had a real system of economics, it would be a lot of players and it seems to me that people would more likely you paid, which automatically translates the profitability of the project.
 And so what? Economics is a project falls
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Gebeleizis "Hultaan" Kapnobatai on February 15, 2015, 02:31:51 pm
Telling Dedicated Logic how to fund their game has never worked in the past, and it is unlikely that it will work this time.

Strangers giving advice about an problem, that they have no inside knowledge of, is like strangers giving advice about a marriage in crisis - better ignored than useful.

We have no insight into the internal politics, the company goals, the real issues and challenges they are facing nor the team dynamics driving this change.

We have only one thing we can do to help - wait for another 6 - 8 months for the showcase game to be released.
No doubt Dedicated Logic will need our help testing the new independent game - the more polished this is, the more likely that their goals will be met.



I personally will be keeping an eye on this forum with the intent of helping out Dedicated Logic with my invaluable time if I am able.


eehmm... I disagree whit u here,

yes it seems all the advice we do, are more likely in vain, they do whatever they want ofc, and in past they proven many times this...still

.... I don't care too much about internal issues, I care about the game, and the product I see, they are grown man , capable to solve issues, and since u mentioned about marriage, I don't think is the kids problem why parents are arguing , and honestly they have to be out of their problem, not involved ..just kept away of the bad things, ..still parents have to solve the issues whitout the kids knowledge...that's life

that is the point, sometimes when u work on something need to see the all picture from a distance, u cant ask an artist to work close to his working project whit out leave it and see how it looks from few steps back, this is the all idea of saying something here on forum, u need fresh eyes into the problem, ..is like u don't see the forest because of the bushes.

and I do strongly believe the game should be prepared for kickstarter, no matter what, a good advertising can sell a poop in a good wrapper, and I know lots of those so called goods sold for huge amount of money. Though here's not the case, AWS has lots of things to be prod of.


imagine this..: AWS as it is now bugged no mining fixed but still u can see how mining works even bugged, hunting the few creatures are around, picking here and there at the edge but u can see how pick works, crafting works ok so far, unbalanced loot but enough to let u see how the trading works ...+ few other things they have to add, the 3 new cities ( as they said those are ready ) new avatar look, few other guns and items they have ready, the cars. And on top of all this, landscapes, concept, beauty of details, dalewj book, wrapped into a good advertise to start the kickstarter....and on the other side the lame games that have raised millions of funds.

yes I dare to say, I dare to believe and I dare to advice, because despite all the issues they might have inside, I see just these stuffs and to me is enough.

cheers
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton on February 15, 2015, 09:32:48 pm

imagine this..: AWS as it is now bugged no mining fixed but still u can see how mining works even bugged, hunting the few creatures are around, picking here and there at the edge but u can see how pick works, crafting works ok so far, unbalanced loot but enough to let u see how the trading works ...+ few other things they have to add, the 3 new cities ( as they said those are ready ) new avatar look, few other guns and items they have ready, the cars. And on top of all this, landscapes, concept, beauty of details, dalewj book, wrapped into a good advertise to start the kickstarter....and on the other side the lame games that have raised millions of funds.

Plus the unique crafting system that makes sense, the ability to know very well what will happen when you hunt, mine, or craft with a little bit of effort, yet still have enough variability to keep things exciting. All of these things combine to make a very compelling game that we have all kept playing and investing into. It's really difficult to come to the same conclusion that Anti and the devs have come to, that the game is too buggy to get funded on Kickstarter. Most of the campaigns on Kickstarter are little more than ideas, hopes, and dreams by completely unknown people who have not shown any ability to come through with their goals, yet nearly 40% of all projects are successfully funded (https://www.kickstarter.com/help/stats).

...despite all the issues they might have inside, I see just these stuffs and to me is enough.

I completely agree. There is absolutely enough for anyone interested to get a very good feel for what this game will become and what the devs are capable of when they have the necessary funding. Yes their timelines have been overly optimistic and their goals have been overly ambitious at times, but in the end you can see what is possible just by playing the game. At the same time, very ambitious goals are exactly what gets people's excitement and anticipation raised up enough for them to become backers, and being able to experience what they've done so far on what is effectively a shoestring budget will make many people say

(http://img.linuxfr.org/img/687474703a2f2f7777772e73747566662d6f2d6d617469632e636f6d2f7074622f6173736574732f636f6d6d756e69636174696f6e2f736875742d75702d616e642d74616b652d6d792d6d6f6e65792e6a7067/shut-up-and-take-my-money.jpg)
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: SPECS2 "POPPS" DATA on February 15, 2015, 11:34:40 pm
sell some land !!! its pretty easy and is a proven method    ;D
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton on February 16, 2015, 06:38:23 am
Hehe, that would definitely bring them lots of cash, but sadly it doesn't seem like they've worked on that capability at all yet.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Nathan "Naro D" Richmond on February 16, 2015, 12:00:38 pm
Am rly sorry to say.
 
But nothing will work here anymore, nothing will help here further on. END.
The current status, for now closed history of aw; aws; is a catastrophy and noone will fund something what, accorded to its history, never will be finished or fully functional or lays in hands that can not actually take care in fulltime.
 
I wish you luck.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: Anti "Ether" Danilevski on February 17, 2015, 10:39:16 am
No, not worked. Alas.
Title: Re: Brace yourself. Bad news and good news - there we go.
Post by: The "Fifth" Entity on February 17, 2015, 12:06:23 pm
Nobody is as blind as the man who doesn't want to see.


There's been several different ways how to build up game economy, decisions had been made about features (like: should the game have new avatars first or rather concentrate on the basic features, etc etc)


However, as i understand it, the current problems are on the completely different level. It is the engine itsellf and it's very basic systems/functions. It's the foundations of everything that is collapsing.
How to solve this problem? It takes a very talented (lead) programmer and lots of work from a dedicated team to work out those issues. There was such a talented programmer, but then something happened along the way, and he decided there's no other way than give it up, and leave.
We don't know all the facts all the exact reasons and probably never will know. Well, it doesn't matter anyhow. Without the working engine and no viable way to fix it there is no future, no way forward.


Another problem we, the playerbase don't want to admit is about us. There is not enough players for the RCE genre. Therefore even the best game would always balance on the edge of abyss. This is the bitter truth.


I truly believe there will be a time when RCE-style game worlds will be much more popular than today, but it will probably take many years and major technological breakthroughs in the gaming industry before the mainstream playerbase will grow and mature to the level to appreciate entertainment like this.


Until then we can only wait for a miracle. Like, the project will go open source and a new ingenious programmer will be found who can solve the monumental problems the AWR team is facing today. I wouldn't hold my breath.