Author Topic: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing  (Read 9098 times)

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« on: March 13, 2014, 08:47:33 am »
Hello everyone.


Currently, we are working on the mobs and their loot. Our goal is to make a system, where mobs would provide enough loot for players, so players would be able to sell that loot for pnotes (which are going to be secondary currency in the game, after AWD). So, while I'm gathering statistic data, you may join the preparation for that rebalance and become part of the process.


How can you participate? Simply by doing three steps:


1. Download this excel file;
2. Fill the columns as you see most realistic;
3. Send the finished excel file to comm(d@g)afterworld.ru


I'll examine our game data and vision of each of you. Later, when I'll finish that work, perhaps you'll notice your contribution to the game.


P.S. I'll be accepting excel files until 16 March 2014. After that time plase don't waste your time filling and sending the file, it won't be accepted.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #1 on: March 13, 2014, 09:57:04 am »
Hi Anti,

Shouldn't the loot gained from mobs, and the drop rate, be linked to items need at a certain Profession level?

For example, I think it would be desirable for New Citizens to be able to hunt, loot  and craft their own HK-A1 (the beginner HK)

To do this they need:

Resource               Qty

Animal blood   75
Birch log   400
Cellular bulk   60
Coal stone   167
Common slag   1,833
Copper stone   780
Distilled water   653
Flock           2,000
Iron stone   300
Light yarn   400
Loox stone   50
Medical plants   667
Process water   70
Sollium stone   400
Sulfur stone   167

These resources need to be near a craft area where the low skilled player can (with a certain amount of difficulty) collect the Mob based resources.
If it is also desired for the new citizen can UG mine the other materials, the mob placement and/or density must not make this an impossible task.

In addition, you need to balance the fact that mobs are used for three activities:
1. Loot
2. Weapons skills
3. Avoidance skills

The 3 activities and the profession levels are likely to make the mob distribution similar to AWA (where, in general, the further you got from Sar the higher skills you needed), with clumps and thinly spread mob distribution to give a mixture of skill levels access to them.

FYI: I was collecting mob maturity, health and damage in AWA to produce a Player Tool to produce mob / maturity trees based on the player's skill levels and which creature they wanted to survive. However, the player filled wiki lacked enough info to complete that task (and I certainly could not survive a significant proportion of the creatures to gather that information easily).

If it is possible to share mob maturity, health and damage (either now or later), this could benefit players. And, as a side benefit by sharing this, you could adjust mob locations, health and damage without having players angrily stating that they just wasted several months working out where mobs where, their health and damage ... and now they have to start for scratch! (with a grrr somewhere in there)
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #2 on: March 13, 2014, 10:41:35 am »
It may be linked, but currently I'm looking for the basic, raw balance that won't include those bonuses/penalties. This is a first step toward the new pnotes economy, though I'm coming to that balance from the distant way - this way we won't have to revamp too much and most of the current game/creatures will stay unharmed by the process.


About sharing mobs toughness - no, won't happen. We are leaving to the players that loves to collect and organize data.
« Last Edit: March 13, 2014, 10:57:54 am by Anti "Ether" Danilevski »
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Leopold "Shaqan" Mutter

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 95
  • I am MALE!
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #3 on: March 13, 2014, 11:02:30 am »
Please explain a bit more the exact meanings of "Subjective difficulty 0-100" and "Subjective kills per hour".

What exactly you devs keep in mind with both, else we could have misunderstandings.

  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: test
  • Member of society: Pleasure and Power
AMD FX-8350 on ASUS M5A99X Evo R2.0, 1x8Gb 1866Mhz DDR3, Creative SoundBlaster Live!, Nvidia Geforce 660Ti
LSI MegaRaid 9260-8i (2xSeagate Cheetah 15k7 600Gb SAS RAID 0)
Intel SASU8I (Initiator-Target mode firmware) Seagate Cheetah 15k7 300Gb SAS
OS:Win7 Pro x64 | OS:OpenSUSE 13.1 x64

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #4 on: March 13, 2014, 11:09:58 am »
Please explain a bit more the exact meanings of "Subjective difficulty 0-100" and "Subjective kills per hour".

What exactly you devs keep in mind with both, else we could have misunderstandings.


There are notes, move your cursor to the red dots at the right top corner of the cell.


Subjective difficulty - it's how hard to kill that mob for you. If it's easiest thing in the world - 0, if you can't kill it no matter how you try - 100.


Subjective kills per hour - how many times you are able to kill this creature per hour, with the current spawn rate.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline The "Fifth" Entity

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 425
    • View Profile
    • 5entity.blogspot.com
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #5 on: March 13, 2014, 12:02:14 pm »

I'm afraid i can't help much in this effort...

Anyway, i'll describe how it looks like for me. 2 considerations, either:
 - there's a specific loot you want to collect, or
 - there's a specific avoidance you want to skill.


Once you have decided what's the goal you open wiki (or your soc's website) and look up what mob and maturity provides what you need.
Next, you select the proper armor for that mob (or craft it, if needed).
Finally, you travel to the area where this mob is located.


There's a third activity - skilling weapons (melee or rifle). This activity itself doesn't depend on any property of the mob, you could shoot the brick wall. As the brick wall doesn't give skills u have to use big warthogs or something. But as weapon skilling itself is "mob-neutral", ppl usually choose the mob according to loot or avoidance.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Alpha Unlimited
  • Member of society: Alpha

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #6 on: March 13, 2014, 12:05:51 pm »
Fifth, imagine that no skills, no drop is existing. You have only two goals: to estimate mobs toughness and to kill those mobs as much as possible in one hour.
Based on this, you are free to throw your estimation, if you want.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Leopold "Shaqan" Mutter

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 95
  • I am MALE!
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #7 on: March 13, 2014, 02:29:33 pm »
So for further clarification (asked from soc channel first, nobody had a clue)

You want us to present you purely with our thoughts. How (and where:that part is clear) we would like to see different creatures in AfterWorld?
All that under following conditions
-We do not think on what they have looted in past or which skills have they been giving out in past. Because it (at least loot is going to be) may be subject to change.
- "Subjective difficulty" means our imagined creature difficulty compared to our present skill levels?

And you do NOT want us actually go out, taking on single creatures at different maturities, killing them while timing it with a stopwatch? Then calculating possible amount in a hour and writing it down into excel file?

I need it written under KISS (keep it simple and stupid) principle, sorry
« Last Edit: March 13, 2014, 02:31:48 pm by Leopold "Shaqan" Mutter »
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: test
  • Member of society: Pleasure and Power
AMD FX-8350 on ASUS M5A99X Evo R2.0, 1x8Gb 1866Mhz DDR3, Creative SoundBlaster Live!, Nvidia Geforce 660Ti
LSI MegaRaid 9260-8i (2xSeagate Cheetah 15k7 600Gb SAS RAID 0)
Intel SASU8I (Initiator-Target mode firmware) Seagate Cheetah 15k7 300Gb SAS
OS:Win7 Pro x64 | OS:OpenSUSE 13.1 x64

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #8 on: March 13, 2014, 03:47:58 pm »
Yes, I'm interesting just in your thoughts. I don't want you to go out and kill three hundred of different monsters, wasting 300 hours of your life :)
I'm just curious about your opinions and subjective perception of the current creatures. Maybe it would affect the future of the game, maybe not. I have my vision and data, but to make it more interesting, I'm giving players a chance to participate in that development. It's up to you all to participate or not.


And don't think about their loot. Just how powerful they are and how many of them you are able to kill in a hour, doing your best.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Gebeleizis "Hultaan" Kapnobatai

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 307
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #9 on: March 13, 2014, 04:10:37 pm »
anti,I have to point something obvious for any players who's main weapon is more than a grom hunter gun, the mobs whit lower HTH like slugroaches cannot be killed whit hight dmg, the msg sais, more or less, " huge dmg destroyed everything u have nothing to loot" I don't see a point to have such feature if I personally chose to kill a small mob whit extra dmg, If for me time means money and I don't want to go down again to Siger to be able to kill a slugroaches,.... is my choice and I pay for that 26 ammo/ shoot .... I can use a sieger whit 4 shoots where r 2ammo/shoot but I don't want, is absurd at least to me , this is similar to other mobs like wolfs, young to old, elslugs, slugots dweebs to weak
« Last Edit: March 13, 2014, 04:15:41 pm by Gebeleizis "Hultaan" Kapnobatai »
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Foundry
  • Member of corporation: Alpha Unlimited
  • Member of society: Alpha
OS: Windows 7 Ultimate 64-bit SP1 (6.1, Build 7601)
System: Alienware M17xR4 (U3E1)
CPU: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-3820QM CPU @ 2.70GHz (8 CPUs), ~2.7GHz Ivy Bridge 22nm Technology
RAM: 8.00 GB Single-Channel DDR3 @ 798MHz (11-11-11-28) Graphic: AMD Radeon HD 7970M (1920x1080@60Hz) DirectX : DirectX 11

Offline Mauler "Gooch" Ruckhard

  • Survival closed test group
  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 94
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #10 on: March 13, 2014, 08:49:40 pm »
yes i agree there really shouldnt be a penalty for people over killing it is better for the devs if people want to waste ammo


it is the same with skilling is a person want to skill with a huge weapons and waste there money that is a penalty enough if there not smart enough to skill with the proper weapon and want to waste huge amounts of ammo there skills shouldnt reduced and that is another reason the sau is a bad idea because now they get penalized for for using a big weapons and the devs loose money because people don't use big weapons to hunt


the damage on a weapon shouldn't change with higher skills
although the skills received should vary


because if any took any gun off a shelf in the gun store it will always do the same damage although people might have better aim and less gun sway as they get better skilled





  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: DILLIGAF
  • Member of society: Irken Invaders

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #11 on: March 13, 2014, 09:08:10 pm »
It will be rebalanced when drop and it's prices are done, mobs are tuned and their living areas are reworked. Weak monsters won't provide enough profit should you hunt them on high levels and should be interesting only for lowbies.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #12 on: March 13, 2014, 09:08:44 pm »
Hi Anti,

I wonder if I have the right idea about what you are asking.

This request is not about the loot, it is about the effort required to kill a creature, the frequency a player can kill a creature and where a play might expect to find a creature (which might be different from it's current Survival location)

More importantly, it is about whether the player at their current level thinks it is too hard (or too easy) to kill lots of certain creature quickly.

I cannot actually help with that as I do not kill creatures for fun, I kill them for their loot. If a Wolf Young is chewing on my leg - I do not automatically reach for a weapon and kill it. I am more likely to heal and ignore it (and move out it's agro range  to prevent the poor thing from committing suicide).
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Paul "Cuey" Darkmane

  • Survival closed test group
  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 242
  • Testing Afterworld Since 2006 (AWTP)
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #13 on: March 13, 2014, 09:21:28 pm »

I'm just curious about your opinions and subjective perception of the current creatures.


in your xls list there are mobs i have fought a lot in awa but are not here in aws yet because they are not in game ... having had experience hunting those mobs as well in the past ,do you want me to fill all the mobs in the list? ... oh i also noticed there are no S.W.A.T.S  on the list.. are you planning in future to bring them back as well>? ... cheers
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Just Because im paranoid,dont mean their not after me!!   <--- Its a line from a Nirvana Song fancy having to explain that,whats the world coming too?!!

Testing Afterworld Since 2006 (AWTP)
Proud Leader of Shadow Corpse!

Offline Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1948
  • AfterWiki admin & Computer Engineer
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Mobs and their drop: rebalancing
« Reply #14 on: March 13, 2014, 10:08:27 pm »
I think I understand based on previous responses, but to be as clear as possible, which is more accurate:

    1. Fill each cell with our opinion of how difficult/rapidly each mob should be killable and their region/population.

or

    2. Fill each cell with our opinion of how difficult/rapidly each mob currently is killable and their region/population.

Also, would you mind if I changed the sort order of the Monster column? It's easier for me if I sort alphabetically by mob name, then by maturity.


@Cuey, I'm noticing that there are other mobs missing from the list too so I think Anti only wants input on the listed mobs, not ALL mobs.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk West at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Proud Officer in Shadow Corpse society and Consolidators corporation.