Author Topic: Skills trading denial (important)  (Read 17009 times)

Offline Zen "ZenX" Star

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 265
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #75 on: March 12, 2014, 04:55:35 am »
I'm not sure you appreciate how hard it is to get avoidances to level 40 Jane.
It takes a long, long time in reality.
I'd like to see someone start the game today and get to level 40 in anything in 3 to 5 months.
It is so exponentially hard as your levels raise.
And if they got close, they wouldn't be playing Afterworld, they would be working it like a machine.

Buying skills, and chippinhg in and out effected timeframes, but this want possible for a lot of the past, and isn't possible in the future.

Zen
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town
  • Member of corporation: Gencorp
  • Member of society: Genesis
Windows 7 Ultimate 64-bit (6.1, Build 7601) Service Pack 1 (7601.win7sp1_gdr.120330-1504)
Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-2600K CPU @ 3.40GHz (8 CPUs), ~3.4GHz
8192MB RAM
DirectX 11 NVIDIA GeForce GTX 560

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #76 on: March 12, 2014, 05:06:10 am »
What I deduce from the statements Anti has made so far is that there is a philosophy change:
  • No pay to win
  • Economy based on material goods only; either looted or crafted (and probably services as well at some stage in future)
  • RCE based on selling material goods / services.
This places it closer to real life and attempts to draw a line between EU type behavior and what is expected in this game.


My concern is whether the skill growth will be impacted.


It is currently 41 times harder to get to a skill to level 40 than to get to the same skill to level 1 (at the same skill point rate).
So if it take a player 1 day to get to level 1 in a single skill using the most effective method possible, they will need 41 days to get to level 40 if they can maintain that rate. This is really hard work just for a single skill and not at all fun.


Buffs may help; something needs to be done otherwise players will soon find themselves grinding for days with little progress towards the ability to move away to another area of AWS.


Looks like it's time to use a different font color, wow!

You are right. Also point 4 and 5 are very important:

4. Skills selling is the best way to earn real money outside of the game (or, rather, were the best way). And A LOT of players used it, and many of them are complaining now. So this hole is now shut and those players should find other ways to earn AWD (which isn't really a problem).

5. It was a huge hole for cheaters who used sni's from their alts for close to zero price. It's another group of players who are currently complaining and unhappy. Well, I have no comments here, except for 'About this, I'm not sad at all'.

About skills growth, there are infinite skills growing. But there, at some point, should be situation where skills are too hard to train for most of the players - it would be the natural cap. If this happens at 50 skill level, or 100 - I have to calculate and prototype. If I see that 100 is better for the playerbase, we can easily tune skill growing formula.

More about skills: we will work on them and rebalance them, their effectiveness and growth rate anyways, as soon as FPS is finished (or maybe even before).
« Last Edit: March 12, 2014, 05:10:02 am by Anti "Ether" Danilevski »
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1948
  • AfterWiki admin & Computer Engineer
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #77 on: March 12, 2014, 05:25:11 am »
Anti, could you please comment more about what you're calling "FPS?" Also, it's sad to hear that there are still people using alts after all this time, but it's not exactly surprising either. If nothing else I hope this change makes them all stop running alts from now on!
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk West at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Proud Officer in Shadow Corpse society and Consolidators corporation.

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #78 on: March 12, 2014, 06:07:14 am »
I'm not sure you appreciate how hard it is to get avoidances to level 40 Jane.
It takes a long, long time in reality.
I'd like to see someone start the game today and get to level 40 in anything in 3 to 5 months.
It is so exponentially hard as your levels raise.
And if they got close, they wouldn't be playing Afterworld, they would be working it like a machine.

Buying skills, and chippinhg in and out effected timeframes, but this want possible for a lot of the past, and isn't possible in the future.

Zen
I think you needed to skill, with the right avoidance level, in AWA, in a the middle of a 20 deep mob that gives a single avoidance to understand how the much of a boost this gives to the skill gain. You would then see that 3 to 5 months is a reasonable goal for ONE avoidance skill.

If the AWS was balanced right, then this could still be achievable here. Gaining the full set of level 40 of avoidance skills within a mere 2.5 years might not be part of the new game plan. However, I'll wait for the buffs to be revealed and tested.this may not be what the game will be designed for.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #79 on: March 12, 2014, 06:20:54 am »
What I deduce from the statements Anti has made so far is that there is a philosophy change:
  • No pay to win
  • Economy based on material goods only; either looted or crafted (and probably services as well at some stage in future)
  • RCE based on selling material goods / services.
This places it closer to real life and attempts to draw a line between EU type behavior and what is expected in this game.


My concern is whether the skill growth will be impacted.


It is currently 41 times harder to get to a skill to level 40 than to get to the same skill to level 1 (at the same skill point rate).
So if it take a player 1 day to get to level 1 in a single skill using the most effective method possible, they will need 41 days to get to level 40 if they can maintain that rate. This is really hard work just for a single skill and not at all fun.


Buffs may help; something needs to be done otherwise players will soon find themselves grinding for days with little progress towards the ability to move away to another area of AWS.


Looks like it's time to use a different font color, wow!

You are right. Also point 4 and 5 are very important:

4. Skills selling is the best way to earn real money outside of the game (or, rather, were the best way). And A LOT of players used it, and many of them are complaining now. So this hole is now shut and those players should find other ways to earn AWD (which isn't really a problem).

5. It was a huge hole for cheaters who used sni's from their alts for close to zero price. It's another group of players who are currently complaining and unhappy. Well, I have no comments here, except for 'About this, I'm not sad at all'.

About skills growth, there are infinite skills growing. But there, at some point, should be situation where skills are too hard to train for most of the players - it would be the natural cap. If this happens at 50 skill level, or 100 - I have to calculate and prototype. If I see that 100 is better for the playerbase, we can easily tune skill growing formula.

More about skills: we will work on them and rebalance them, their effectiveness and growth rate anyways, as soon as FPS is finished (or maybe even before).
Thanks Anti :)
I look forward to seeing how this rebalancing works out .... I am really quite curious about all these changes (and less worried thanks to your communications!).
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #80 on: March 12, 2014, 06:31:15 am »
Anti, could you please comment more about what you're calling "FPS?" Also, it's sad to hear that there are still people using alts after all this time, but it's not exactly surprising either. If nothing else I hope this change makes them all stop running alts from now on!


FPS - First Person Shooter. We came to conclusion that the current combat gameplay is outdated, boring and won't be intersting for the newcomers who got used to modern combat games. So we are moving towards a more realistic way to fight. More realistic also means faster, without those 1-2 seconds delays between shots. Of course, damage per each shot would be nerfed, as well as armors and mobs damage. Those changes would also affect skills, death system, loot, PvP and almost everything else in the game. This change (to FPS gameplay) is coming next as soon as server clusterization is finished and will require several months of work, so don't expect it too soon.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline oOoOo "Mantra" oOoOo

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 96
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #81 on: March 12, 2014, 06:41:15 am »
If we can not insert/extract skills, than what is the use of sau? Naturally skilling should produce enough sau for the player for unlocking levels, so has no real point in it. It seems to me the sau should be removed from the game along with the locked/unlocked level concept.


  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q]
  • Member of corporation: World Trading Federation
  • Member of society: N A P

Offline Windslow "Windslow" Warrior

  • Survival closed test group
  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 43
  • Irken Invader
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #82 on: March 12, 2014, 07:22:44 am »
Just wanted to try and list the skills I remember sni'ing because of huge gaps in skilling process and pay to win aspect:
  • Terminal Interaction
  • Materials Technology
  • Computers
There's a lot more than these so hopefully people can start listing their skill gaps to help focus the developers statistical analysis of the gaps in the current skill system.
I don't remember the exact stages (nor do I want to list them publicly) but hopefully this information can speed up the analysis and improvements can be made sooner rather than later.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk West at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: DILLIGAF
  • Member of society: Irken Invaders
OS: Microsoft Windows 7 Pro SP1
CPU: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7 CPU 930 @ 2.80GHz
Motherboard: Gigabyte X58A-UD3R
Memory: 6.00 GB DDR3 10700/1333 Graphics: ATI Radeon HD 5770 1Gb GDDR5 Hard Disk: Western Digital Black 500GB 7200RPM Network: 7.2Mbps Wireless Broadband

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #83 on: March 12, 2014, 07:43:35 am »
Anti, could you please comment more about what you're calling "FPS?" Also, it's sad to hear that there are still people using alts after all this time, but it's not exactly surprising either. If nothing else I hope this change makes them all stop running alts from now on!

FPS - First Person Shooter. We came to conclusion that the current combat gameplay is outdated, boring and won't be intersting for the newcomers who got used to modern combat games. So we are moving towards a more realistic way to fight. More realistic also means faster, without those 1-2 seconds delays between shots. Of course, damage per each shot would be nerfed, as well as armors and mobs damage. Those changes would also affect skills, death system, loot, PvP and almost everything else in the game. This change (to FPS gameplay) is coming next as soon as server clusterization is finished and will require several months of work, so don't expect it too soon.
OMG - Yes!
No more watching that yellow bar inch its way to completion.

Ummm - what about the other side of  the equation ... healing.
Get rid of Heal Kits? Leave nature to heal the wounds?
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #84 on: March 12, 2014, 08:40:52 am »
If we can not insert/extract skills, than what is the use of sau? Naturally skilling should produce enough sau for the player for unlocking levels, so has no real point in it. It seems to me the sau should be removed from the game along with the locked/unlocked level concept.


We are planning to remove SAU from the game, but keep the training skill as requirement. Payment would be in pnotes. There are going to be a huge rebalancing work, that would affect the mobs drop and drop prices, would require to add more shops and traders to the game who would buy items that you get from the hunting. some other ingame activity would also provide pnotes, like quests or likely even trading between cities (under consideration yet).

This would allow players to sell pnotes very much like they were selling SAU to those who need them, stimulate hunting, adventures and etc. Those who don't like grinding would likely earn pnotes via trading/traveling, completing quests and etc (including coprotations activity that we are planning to add). It's better than SAU for many reasons, mainly - because it won't punish players for using weapons they want to use, and yet players would have to do something to unlock the new levels of the skills.

Another positive effect on the game - pnotes would become a really important in-game currency, secondary to AWD, and would allow players to earn AWD in game via selling pnotes on auctions. Those who don't want to waste time on anything but PvP would be free to buy pnotes from other players on auctions.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #85 on: March 12, 2014, 08:42:28 am »
OMG - Yes!
No more watching that yellow bar inch its way to completion.

Ummm - what about the other side of  the equation ... healing.
Get rid of Heal Kits? Leave nature to heal the wounds?


Heal kits will be still in the game, though they will be reworked too to fit the new, more active and fast, gameplay.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline The "Fifth" Entity

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 425
    • View Profile
    • 5entity.blogspot.com
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #86 on: March 12, 2014, 09:11:25 am »
The skilling up calculations are missing one intermediate level. It takes several skillgains (green line in your chat window) to make one whole skillpoint (that you can see in your skills interface). The amount of skillgains per one skillpoint is a variable that increases with skill level.


... pnotes would become a really important in-game currency, secondary to AWD, and would allow players to earn AWD in game via selling pnotes on auctions. Those who don't want to waste time on anything but PvP would be free to buy pnotes from other players on auctions.
Sounds like RCE version of Fallen Earth?

(In Fallen Earth the PvP folks form the "upper class", for them all valuable resources and all the best weapons comes easy. PvP is based on real life skills. Those who can't or don't want to participate in PvP are the "lower class", for them the game provides numerous PVE quests and considerably longer/harder grind.)
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Alpha Unlimited
  • Member of society: Alpha

Offline Anti "Ether" Danilevski

  • AW State Security Bureau
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 392
    • View Profile
    • Gamedis - game design blog (russian)
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #87 on: March 12, 2014, 09:30:17 am »
Sounds like RCE version of Fallen Earth?

(In Fallen Earth the PvP folks form the "upper class", for them all valuable resources and all the best weapons comes easy. PvP is based on real life skills. Those who can't or don't want to participate in PvP are the "lower class", for them the game provides numerous PVE quests and considerably longer/harder grind.)


I don't believe in 'upper' or 'lower' classes. Some players don't like PvP and loves PvE - that's fine, why they are 'bad'? Some will prefer trading to corporation wars, some - vice versa. If someone want to earn AWD via selling pnotes, it's fine. If someone crafting items for sale - it's fine too. And if someone don't care for PvE or craft and can buy pnotes/items from other players for AWD, that's fine too. Our goal is to make the game fun for everyone.
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Foundry, accessing Foundry Terminal
My game design blog - www.gamedis.ru

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #88 on: March 12, 2014, 11:24:54 am »
The skilling up calculations are missing one intermediate level. It takes several skillgains (green line in your chat window) to make one whole skillpoint (that you can see in your skills interface). The amount of skillgains per one skillpoint is a variable that increases with skill level.

If this is a reference to my statements regarding skilling effort, then the answer is that this depends on the distribution of the skills within the profession the skilling activity belongs to; and whether the skill category is item based or not.

The amount of skillgains per one skillpoint is a variable that increases with skill level only applies to profession item based skills (see below).

The easy to explain skills are the Avoidance skills, Training skills and Taming skills - these are not item based activities and every 20 SAU you get results in 1 skill point.

The profession item skilling are much harder to explain due the the skilling rate vs. SAU gain rate.
The way I relate these to skill points is that the game generates 100% SAU value in the background when an item is used - it then applies the items skilling rate (0 - 100%) to the SAU and applies the result to all skills within the profession that the item belongs to based on that skills fixed distribution % for the profession (see  http://jaws.99k.org/Skill%20Advice/_index.html).

Then the item's SAU gain rate (0 - 100%) is applied to the internal 100% SAU value to give SAU to the player.

So at 100% skilling rate & 100% SAU gain rate - every 20 SAU gained by the player represents 1 skill point and that skill point is distributed between the item's professions skills.

Avoidance skills, Training skills and Taming skills are the easiest to maintain a steady skill point increase as they are simply related to your avoidance skill and the creature.

Item based skills are much harder to maintain, not only do you need to find the right creature - you need to find the right item to use against it (i.e. the one which is closes to 100% skill rate ... and hopefully 100% SAU gain rate - otherwise you end up blocking skills).

Unlike Avoidance skills, the profession item skill points gained per second are limited by the item used - so an attack skill (e.g. blades for profession Swordsman) is limited to something like 0.051 skill points per hit (max 6 SAU per hit = 0.3 SP. Blades distribution for Swordsman ~17% --> 0.3SP x 17%= 0.051 SP). So it takes minimum of 20 hits to generate 1 blades skill point ... and that does not change too much between level 1 items vs level 40 items.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Serenity "SerenityFireFly" FireFly

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 374
    • View Profile
    • Shadow Corpse Society Website!
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: Skills trading denial (important)
« Reply #89 on: March 12, 2014, 12:01:37 pm »
Bringing this thread back to topic, i think Sau should stay as needed and sold because it will always be needed to advance levels and besides... For us old oldies we still remember when 100 lon made 1 Lod and we were having to hunt for that which later these lod/lons became sau always has been a key part of game.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Proud Co Founder/Co General of Shadow Corpse Society Since 2006, Afterworld Tester since 2006.