Author Topic: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion  (Read 684 times)

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« on: June 15, 2014, 01:18:21 am »
Is "RCE = Zero Sum Game"?

What sounds like an easy debate turns contentious.
The original topic is Player Incentives for those that wish to see the origins.

The debate so far:

Wow. That is a bad trip.
Must try different drugs.
Ewww - green ones. Gimme!
Wait what? Either u got the green ones before u posted or... i'm hopelessly lost.


Anyway, the logic goes like this:


RCE = zero sum game. As much $$$ as goes into game can come out too (minus a certain fee).
In a zero sum game the rules are very strict. Have to take care u always keep the overall balance and don't give players too much resources.


Not RCE = all $$$ goes in, nothing gets out.
As this is not a zero sum game, there's no need to worry about strict balance. Can give players lot of resources now and then, as a virtual carrot.



RCE = zero sum game. As much $$$ as goes into game can come out too (minus a certain fee).
In a zero sum game the rules are very strict. Have to take care u always keep the overall balance and don't give players too much resources.

What?


It is not as if we are playing a friendly game of poker in a friend's house (total money in players pockets at any point in time = money brought in) -> zero sum game.
It is more like a casino, total money in players pockets < money brought in as the House always makes a profit.


Except in Survival there is no gambling side.
It is almost self-deterministic, which is why Anti had to change the game - the self-deterministic side was that DL would be bankrupt.


So players will never see the zero sum side as the sum is (money in) - (game fees) - (operation costs) - (owners profit) - (asset capital) = (money available for withdrawal).
The result is (money available for withdrawal) << (money in).


Unless you are running a Ponzi scheme.
Which DL is not.
Hopefully.



It is not as if we are playing a friendly game of poker in a friend's house (total money in players pockets at any point in time = money brought in) -> zero sum game.
It is more like a casino, total money in players pockets < money brought in as the House always makes a profit.

1st you ask "What?" and then you say exactly the same as i just said:
As much $$$ as goes into game can come out too (minus a certain fee).
Why? Reading comprehension much?


Except in Survival there is no gambling side.

First, it's quite hard to imagine any real gambling in a casino where you can never have what you won. You can collect a pile of cash and then look at it, through the bulletproof glass.
Second, Survival already has an element of luck. SAU globals, remember?
The question OP has raised is if we could increase the luck factor?


It is almost self-deterministic, which is why Anti had to change the game - the self-deterministic side was that DL would be bankrupt.
Long sentence on Chinese, the famous Jane dialect. There is no other people in the world who can read this dialect. There's been countless attempts to decipher those mysterious messages, they have all failed. We will not try it again.


Compare next two quotes. Both say the same. Which one is shorter? 
As much $$$ as goes into game can come out too (minus a certain fee).

So players will never see the zero sum side as the sum is (money in) - (game fees) - (operation costs) - (owners profit) - (asset capital) = (money available for withdrawal).
The result is (money available for withdrawal) << (money in).


Unless you are running a Ponzi scheme.
Which DL is not.
Hopefully.



Green stuff ftw!!!





Quote
RCE = zero sum game

Casinos do not run as a zero sum game.
zero sum game applies to closed systems.
Survival is not a closed system.


Quote
Many economic situations are not zero-sum, since valuable goods and services can be created, destroyed, or badly allocated in a number of ways, and any of these will create a net gain or loss of utility to numerous stakeholders. Specifically, all trade is by definition positive sum, because when two parties agree to an exchange each party must consider the goods it is receiving to be more valuable than the goods it is delivering. In fact, all economic exchanges must benefit both parties to the point that each party can overcome its transaction costs, or the transaction would simply not take place



Resistance is useless. You will be assimilated.



Casinos do not run as a zero sum game.
zero sum game applies to closed systems.
Survival is not a closed system.
Ooh, i think i finally understand what causes all that confusion you seem have with understanding RCE concept.
I can try to explain, althou i will be annihilated in the end. But it doesn't matter, let's take it easy like a good mind game. ;)


Unlike real life economic systems, virtual economies don't produce any real added value inside the system.
Instead, just like any closed system, they are consuming resources to keep the system running.


Taking the above into account, we can view it as a closed system and apply the laws of thermodynamics:
  • In any closed system, you cannot create new energy (first law of thermodynamics)
  • You always lose a little energy (second law of thermodynamics)
  • Therefore a machine cannot make more energy than it uses or even enough to keep itself operating.
(Notice, in the closed virtual model of the Universe, the Entropy is always slowly increasing... ;) )


Next step. We will now simplify our model and remove the maintenance fees from the equation.


If we now look at it we will discover it has turned into a classical zero sum game - as much as goes in, comes out.
From our standpoint it is unimportant what exactly goes on inside the system. The resources might change hands inside there, or they might not. From our standpoint (looking at the system from the outside) any transactions inside there are absolutely irrelevant because the total input is still exactly equal to the total output.


Notice, RCE operates like Outer Shell. For RCE it's irrelevant what principle is used by the Inner System to redistribute resources between players. Maybe it's based on luck ("Casino"), or time and effort ("Slave labor") or maybe there is no redistribution at all. The only publicly known RCE is largely based on luck, therefore ppl think RCE = Casino, but this is only a coincidence, two separate facts that have no casual connection.



Now, coming back to the topic - Survival is indeed not a closed system. Total input is 100%, total output is 0%. Those values are not equal and there's no need to worry about balance inside the system. This setup gives us a lot of freedom - we can create new resources out of the thin air and inject them into system. Unless we oversupply the system by a magnitude, nothing happens. I mean, there's no need to carefully count every penny 'cause the next moment ppl might want to convert all these resources into real money and withdraw it from the system.



Actually, it can easily argued that AfterWorld (in all its editions and versions) is not a closed system - which describes "a physical system which does not allow certain types of transfers in or out" - but actually a more restrictive (though still not physical) isolated system, at least from the player's point of view.


Consider the fact that we, as players, have absolutely no way of directly introducing or removing any items from within the game. What we do instead is pay money to the devs, who then change a variable on our avatar's database object so that our avatar now has more AWD. While this has an effect on the in-game economy, it is not actually introducing anything new into the game. The only thing that can either add or remove game items, creatures, players, etc. is a change in the underlying code itself, which can only be done (again) by the devs. It may feel like we're creating AWD from money, but that's only because of the abstraction of the dollar-to-AWD transaction system, especially now that it's automated.


In a very direct way, this is very similar to WoW or any other subscription-based game. You pay money to the devs and they allow you to log into the game to do things with your avatar (though, of course, the AW devs don't take away this ability just because we stop giving them money).



This is not the disagreement Fifth and Jane are really having though. The fact that we cannot currently take any money back out of the game effectively makes AW a closed system from our real-world wallets' point of view. Until there is a way to withdraw AWD back into dollars it will remain a closed system, but even then it will be a very inefficient resource conversion system since the vast majority of us will never get back 100% of the dollars we have put in, let alone make a profit.


P.S.: That other Universe seems to actually have a rapidly increasing Entropy from my wallet's point of view!



Unfortunately Survival cannot be considered a Closed System as a closed system is not allowed to have any INPUTs.
Survival fails to work without AWD input.


Fifths and my discussion is about "RCE = zero sum game". I do not think it can be. Fifth thinks it is. It might be a case of scale.


As IMHO, a zero sum game needs to be a Closed System.
Survival (with/without planned withdrawal option) is not a closed system. Nor is it a closed system if you extend the boundaries to include DL business plan.



Fifth is correct in that RCE can be, if implemented correctly, a zero sum game minus DL costs and profits.
ZSG is simply that what player A takes out is provided by player B.


Its not complex, its just another concept.


Whether Survival uses this model is unknown.


Zen





@ ZenX


I agree that if you take into account all the costs against the inputs then the remainder could be used as output.
Input: $ #1
Costs:
  • $ to AWD fees
  • Terminal fees
  • DL operating costs
  • DL stakeholder dividends
  • Debt repayment
  • In-game to $ fees
Output: $ #2 < $ #1


That is not what a Zero Sum Game means as you are talking about players. Zero Sum Game definition has the concept of "If the total gains of the participants are added up, and the total losses are subtracted, they will sum to zero." DL are not participants in this instance, they are a leakage resulting in an open system.


However, let's pretend you actually do know what you are talking about.


Since "Its not complex" you will be able to easily post a comprehensive example where two players (and only two players) interact with the game and show that they are involved in a Zero Sum Game.


I look forward to reviewing that.



Jane, being insulting does nothing for how people see you, it doesn't help me, it doesn't help Survival, it only feeds your ego.


I was putting forward that what Fifth said is correct,
A zero sum game is most definitely a situation in which one person’s gain is equivalent to another’s loss, so the net change in wealth or benefit is zero.
Dispute that if you wish, that is your choice, but you would be wrong.
Fifth qualified his/her statement by stating 'minus fees'.
Fees is the worth of expenses and profits.


I agreed that Fifth's qualified statement is workable, and is correct, and is a variation on RCE, and a variation on ZSG, as he/she qualified in his/her post.


Jane, it would help if you could consider that others may have differing views and concepts, and being insulting is simply not nice.


Zen



Jane, being insulting does nothing for how people see you, it doesn't help me, it doesn't help Survival, it only feeds your ego.


I was putting forward that what Fifth said is correct,
A zero sum game is most definitely a situation in which one person’s gain is equivalent to another’s loss, so the net change in wealth or benefit is zero.
Dispute that if you wish, that is your choice, but you would be wrong.
Fifth qualified his/her statement by stating 'minus fees'.
Fees is the worth of expenses and profits.


I agreed that Fifth's qualified statement is workable, and is correct, and is a variation on RCE, and a variation on ZSG, as he/she qualified in his/her post.


Jane, it would help if you could consider that others may have differing views and concepts, and being insulting is simply not nice.


Zen

I take that as a "No. I am unable to produce a working example".
I'll let the community decide what that actually means in terms for your credibility.



Jane, the example is in my post, if you don't understand it just don't reply.


Please stop trying to take ownership of every thread, it would be nice to express an opinion or a concept without an attack by yourself.
Thank


Zen



Jane, the example is in my post, if you don't understand it just don't reply.


Please stop trying to take ownership of every thread, it would be nice to express an opinion or a concept without an attack by yourself.
Thank


Zen

You silly goose, there is no example in your posts. I agree with so-and-so and I am right is not an example.
Any attempt to disagree with you, you take as an insult 


Fifth, FYI, none of this is applies to you. You are a great debater and give intelligent, well thought out arguments (sometimes with fantastically showstopping  sarcastic / humorous spin!).
« Last Edit: June 15, 2014, 01:30:40 am by Event "Janе" Horizon »
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1948
  • AfterWiki admin & Computer Engineer
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #1 on: June 15, 2014, 03:15:13 am »
Quote
Unfortunately Survival cannot be considered a Closed System as a closed system is not allowed to have any INPUTs.
Survival fails to work without AWD input.
Actually, AfterWorld as a game fails altogether with no input. Without input it is merely a simulation without very much going on since mobs don't attack each other. Thus the only truly closed systems are those contained entirely inside of computer systems, with any given entity within it running entirely on pre-determined rules from pre-determine stimuli.


Anyway I agree with Zen that there are different perspectives to take on the ZSG discussion. But if you only want to consider the dictionary definition of the game as a whole, then yes, AW is not a zero sum game.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk West at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Proud Officer in Shadow Corpse society and Consolidators corporation.

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #2 on: June 15, 2014, 04:25:37 am »
Hmmm - I have already worked out that others have a non-standard definition of Zero Sum Game.
Unfortunately, Zero Sum Game is not ambiguous. Having a non-standard definition this has the same usefulness as having a non-standard definition of 1 + 1.

So for these people, the equality is ...

RCE = something I like to call Zero Sum Game but does not sum to zero and is something different to the term commonly used.

The apparent non-standard use of the term is why I ask for clarification.
Some find being asked for clarification an insult to their what-nots.
« Last Edit: June 15, 2014, 05:03:38 am by Event "Janе" Horizon »
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline Jarod "Brickwit" McBrickerton

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1948
  • AfterWiki admin & Computer Engineer
    • View Profile
  • Gender: Male [Male]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #3 on: June 16, 2014, 04:10:43 am »
Well, from the very Wikipedia article you quote is the definition, "In game theory and economic theory, a zero-sum game is a mathematical representation of a situation in which a participant's gain (or loss) of utility is exactly balanced by the losses (or gains) of the utility of the other participant(s)." The term "utility" can mean a lot of different things; for me the utility of AW is the fun I have playing it while for others it's the value of money invested. So saying that other interpretations are "non-standard" compared to the "real" definition leads to the impression that in your opinion the only "real" definition is your definition.

The Wikipedia page then says, "A zero-sum game is also called a strictly competitive game while non-zero-sum games can be either competitive or non-competitive." Because AW is allows for both competitive and non-competitive play, it is not zero-sum overall. However, from the perspective that says "All I care about is the money I get back from my investment, which is determined by the actions of other players," AW is purely competitive and therefore zero-sum.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk West at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Consolidators
  • Member of society: Shadow Corpse
Proud Officer in Shadow Corpse society and Consolidators corporation.

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #4 on: June 16, 2014, 05:47:29 am »
The wiki ZSG definition has a better, um, definition than the overview:
The zero-sum property (if one gains, another loses) means that any result of a zero-sum situation is Pareto optimal (generally, any game where all strategies are Pareto optimal is called a conflict game).

Which I guess means that unless your fun is exactly matched by someone else's negative-fun  ??? ; you are not in a ZSG.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html

Offline The "Fifth" Entity

  • Survival closed test group
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 425
    • View Profile
    • 5entity.blogspot.com
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #5 on: June 16, 2014, 06:52:14 am »
The explanation contains all the logical steps needed to understand the transactions between the virtual and real world in RCE:

Quote
We will now simplify our model and remove the maintenance fees from the equation.
If we now look at it we will discover it has turned into a classical zero sum game - as much as goes in, comes out.
From our standpoint it is unimportant what exactly goes on inside the system. The resources might change hands inside there, or they might not. From our standpoint (looking at the system from the outside) any transactions inside there are absolutely irrelevant because the total input is still exactly equal to the total output.


Jane's argument is, that we are not allowed to simplify the model to make it easier to understand. This is a strange idea. :)

I think everybody who wants to understand the concept has already understood it.
My last attempt to explain it to Jane failed and i was annihilated in the end. There will be no further attempts.
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in Saransk, Town at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Alpha Unlimited
  • Member of society: Alpha

Offline Event "Janе" Horizon

  • Survival closed test group
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1773
  • Humble makes pie. Don't make pie, be AWESOME.
    • View Profile
    • Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
  • Gender: Female [Female]
  • In game: No
  • State: Human
Re: RCE = Zero Sum Game Discussion
« Reply #6 on: June 16, 2014, 07:39:14 pm »
Well, Fifth, your model is invalid. Fees cannot be removed from the equation as they are an integral part of this game.
You might as well simplify your model to exclude terminal fees, then AWD is not required ... and then you definitely will have a ZSG  ::)

And it is assimilated (unless your are a Borg  :o in which case annihilated is the end result).
  • Citizenship: Regular citizen
  • Last seen in New Urengoy [Q] at Outpost / Storages
  • Member of corporation: Savonation
  • Member of society: Savonites
NEVER DOUBT yourself. YOU ARE intelligent, forgiving and AWESOME.

Jane's AfterWorld Secrets
http://jaws.altervista.org/index.html